The French authorities anticipate that people will primarily switch to high speed train rather than to coaches or cars. Available data referred to [See ‘High-speed rail: lessons for policy makers from experiences abroad’, D Albalate, G Bel – Public Administration Review (2012) (referred to in the French letter of 17 November 2021).] seem to point to a historical preference for rail connections amongst the people who use air connections. To obtain estimates on the potential impact of the modal shift on emission reductions, the French authorities calculated two extreme scenarios for the Orly-Bordeaux route: according to the French authorities, the Measure would result in the worst-case scenario [The assumption is that ‘air passengers would switch to road and rail in the same proportions as passengers already travelling on these alternative modes of transport at times when there was a flight available (overlooking the ‘other’ reason). The proportions applied are taken from the 2019 People’s Mobility Survey’. They however add that ‘a worst-case scenario must be assumed for the switch to road transport to halve the gains from the closure of the air route’.] to a reduction of CO2 emissions by almost 50 % (-48,2 %) and in the best-case scenario (full modal shift to rail) to 98,3 % less emissions.
43 III. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › The measure should not be more restrictive than necessary to relieve the problems, Decision_act (EU) 2022/2358
In forcesince 1 Dec 2022