The Commission services established during its examination that:
Rowerland complied with the de minimis rule as stated in recital (13) both in terms of volumes of bicycles parts purchased and used for the assembly activity, and as verified through volumes of bicycles assembled;
the figures used by the company to demonstrate compliance with anti-circumvention rules could be reconciled with those recorded in the accounting system;
the accounting system used by Rowerland did not allow the company to track the origin of the bicycle parts purchased and used in the assembly operations and therefore the 60-40 % criterion could not be assessed;
the investigation revealed that Rowerland did not manufacture any bicycle parts, apart from bicycle wheels;
in accordance with the documentation and explanations provided by Rowerland during the verification process, several costs reported by Rowerland as value added were amended as detailed under points (i)-(ii) below, while other costs as detailed under points (iii)-(v) below were not accepted as costs directly linked to the assembly activities:
the amount reported as direct energy costs was calculated by Rowerland on the basis of the number of the workers assigned to the assembly operations while the amount reported as indirect energy costs was calculated on the basis of the number of the administrative employees. This methodology was not considered appropriate since the energy costs are linked to the premises where the assembly operations take place and not to the number of employees. Therefore, the energy costs were thus recalculated and allocated on the basis of the square meters of the premises where the assembly operations were carried out (direct energy costs) and of the square meters of the office and of the warehouses where the bicycles parts were stored (indirect energy costs);
the amount reported by Rowerland as rent/lease and listed as indirect manufacturing cost was amended due to a clerical error;
the amount reported by Rowerland as indirect energy costs included energy costs for premises not linked to the company’s assembly operations. Therefore, these costs were disregarded from the manufacturing costs of the bicycles;
the amount reported by Rowerland under ‘other direct manufacturing costs’ included costs relating to painting of bicycle parts not used during the investigation period. Therefore, these costs were also disregarded from the manufacturing costs of the bicycles assembled during the investigation period;
the amount reported by Rowerland as depreciation included depreciation for all the buildings, facilities and premises of the company. The company did not report any depreciation for machinery as the limited equipment owned by the company had already been depreciated. As the depreciation of the commercial building (shop) and relating warehouses was not linked to assembly operations, it was considered as administrative expenses and not part of the manufacturing costs.
after recalculation, the value added to the parts brought in by Rowerland during the assembly operation amounted to less than 25 % of the manufacturing cost.