After final disclosure, the Jindal group claimed that the export price adjustment for EU sales routed through JSL Global Commodities Pte. Ltd (‘JGC’) should not exceed its SG&A costs, because as per the institutions’ past practice and as sanctioned by the Court of First Instance, it would be reasonable to deduct only SG&A costs. [Judgment of 18 March 2009, Shanghai Excell M&E Enterprise, T-299/05, EU:T:2009:72, para. 288] If the Commission insists on including a profit (which it should not), that profit should be based on JGC’s data. According to the Jindal Group, this would be in line with the Commission’s recent practice and the Court of First Instance’s consideration that it is ‘reasonable’ to use ‘genuine data’ [See, e.g., recital (283) to Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/582 of 9 April 2021 imposing a provisional anti-dumping duty on imports of aluminium flat-rolled products originating in the People’s Republic of China, OJ L 124, 12.4.2021, p. 40 (using the profit of ‘the trader’ at issue); judgment of 18 March 2009, Shanghai Excell M&E Enterprise, T-299/05, EU:T:2009:72, para. 287.].
54 3. DUMPING › 3.1. India › 3.1.4. Comparison, Regulation (EU) 2021/2012
In forcesince 17 Nov 2021
Judgment of the Court of First Instance (First Chamber) of 18 March 2009. Shanghai Excell M&E Enterprise Co. Ltd and Shanghai Adeptech PreciDecision
18 Mar 2009 · 62005TJ0299