42 G. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS AND HEARINGS, Regulation (EU) 2020/1216

In forcesince 24 Aug 2020

The Commission examines whether a company respects’ the undertaking in light of the terms of the undertaking.. The terms of the undertaking were accepted by the exporting producer. In return, it is entitled to the form of trade defence measures that is most favourable to it, because it enables it, provided it complies with the undertaking, to avoid paying duties. [Judgment in Neotype v Commission, C-305/86 and C-160/87, EU:C:1990:295, para. 60; and in International Potash v Council, T-87/98, EU:T:2000:221, para. 41 and case-law quoted.] Therefore, applying the normal form of duties in a situation where the exporting producer breached the undertaking is not disproportionate, but simply the application of the normal rules, because a breach of the undertaking does not justify the most favourable treatment. The only argument invoked by Trunsun Solar to justify why invalidation would be disproportionate is because it alleges that it complied, in substance, with the variable duty MIP when importing the goods. This argument already fails for the simple reason that the question of actual dumping of a concrete export transaction is relevant only for a possible refund pursuant to Article 11(8) of the basic anti-dumping Regulation. [Judgment in International Potash v Council, T-87/98, EU:T:2000:221, para. 35: ‘It must be emphasised that the basic regulation does not permit any factors other than those in respect of which findings are made during the period of investigation, such as, for example, the “actual” dumping margin for future export transactions, to be taken into account for the purposes of fixing the dumping margin. A Council regulation imposing anti-dumping duties must be based on facts established following a procedure in which interested parties make known their views (see Case 240/84 NTN Toyo v Council [1987] ECR 1809, paragraph 26). Thus, under the basic regulation, the concept of an “actual” dumping margin is relevant only in the context of procedures for the review of existing duties or the refund of duty collected, which are referred to in paragraphs (3) and (8) respectively of Article 11 of the regulation’.] If indeed, as a result of the respect of the MIP, the dumping margin of the concrete export has been reduced or even annihilated, the importer can ask for a refund. In addition, the Commission notes that when the breach occurred, there was no guarantee that customs clearance would indeed take place after 30 September 2017. In this case, the Commission takes the view that Trunsun Solar breached its undertaking obligations as detailed in recital 25. Thus the claim that the Commission’s proposal is disproportionate is rejected.

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 11 July 1990. Neotype Techmashexport GmbH v Commission and Council of the European Communities.Decision

    11 Jul 1990 · 61986CJ0305

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Third Chamber, extended composition) of 29 September 2000. International Potash Company v Council oDecision

    29 Sep 2000 · 61998TJ0087

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 7 May 1987. NTN Toyo Bearing Company Limited and others v Council of the European Communities.Decision

    7 May 1987 · 61984CJ0240

  • celex=31987R0098