First, the Commission notes that Trunsun Solar could only issue undertaking invoices while the undertaking was in force. It was prohibited from issuing commercial invoices in accordance with the stipulations of Annex V and Annex 4 to the expiry review anti-dumping and anti-subsidy Regulations respectively. It was precisely in that spirit that the Commission clarified on 20 September 2017 that imports of solar panels accompanied by an undertaking invoice and certificate and customs-cleared as from 1 October would be subject to and compliant with the repeal Regulation. Second, while Trunsun Solar claimed to have re-issued the variable duty MIP invoices after 20 September 2017 the Commission notes that the large majority of the solar panels in question had already been shipped to the EU before that date and therefore could have only been shipped with the corresponding undertaking invoice. Third, by re-issuing the variable duty MIP invoices at a lower price and value, to its commercial detriment, to replace the undertaking invoices for solar panels that had already been shipped to the importer, Trunsun Solar put into question the spirit and effectiveness of the undertaking. Fourth, Trunsun Solar re-issued the invoices because it anticipated that the solar panels in question would be released for free circulation under the repeal Regulation. No other commercial justification as regards the solar panels in question triggered the decrease in price. Finally, Trunsun Solar did not report to the Commission the sales in question at their real value, but at the value and price of the undertaking invoice even though the reporting was done long after the lower-value variable duty MIP invoices were issued. In light of the above, the Commission considers that the sales listed in recital 26 were concluded under the undertaking and that should have been accompanied by the corresponding undertaking invoice and certificate, and that the price had to comply with the undertaking price.
37 G. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS AND HEARINGS, Regulation (EU) 2020/1216
In forcesince 24 Aug 2020