2. ASSESSMENT › 2.1. Admissibility › 2.1.1. On the pre-existence of the notified national provisions, Decision_act (EU) 2020/1205

In forcesince 6 Aug 2020
(52)

This distinction has been addressed by case law of the Court. In the case C-3/00 Denmark v Commission, the Court concluded with respect to Article 95 TEC, which corresponds to Article 114 TFEU:

‘The difference between the two situations envisaged in Article 95 is that, in the first, the national provisions predate the harmonisation measure. They are thus known to the Community legislature, but the legislature cannot or does not seek to be guided by them for the purpose of harmonisation. It is therefore considered acceptable for the Member State to request that its own rules remain in force. To that end, the EC Treaty requires that such national provisions must be justified on grounds of the major needs referred to in Article 30 EC or relating to the protection of the environment or the working environment. By contrast, in the second situation, the adoption of new national legislation is more likely to jeopardise harmonisation. The Community institutions could not, by definition, have taken account of the national text when drawing up the harmonisation measure. In that case, the requirements referred to in Article 30 EC are not taken into account, and only grounds relating to protection of the environment or the working environment are accepted, on condition that the Member State provides new scientific evidence and that the need to introduce new national provisions results from a problem specific to the Member State concerned arising after the adoption of the harmonisation measure’ [C-3/00 Denmark v Commission, paragraph 58. Further confirmed in e.g. T-234/04 Kingdom of the Netherlands v Commission, paragraph 58, Joined Cases T-366/03 and T-235/04 Land Oberösterreich and Austria v Commission, paragraph 62 and C-512/99 Germany v Commission, paragraph 41.].

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Fourth Chamber) of 5 October 2005. Land Oberösterreich and Republic of Austria v Commission of the Decision

    5 Oct 2005 · 62003TJ0366

  • Treaty establishing the European Community9530Law

  • Judgment of the Court of 21 January 2003. Federal Republic of Germany v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    21 Jan 2003 · 61999CJ0512

  • Judgment of the Court of 20 March 2003. Kingdom of Denmark v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    20 Mar 2003 · 62000CJ0003

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Fifth Chamber, extended composition) of 8 November 2007. Kingdom of the Netherlands v Commission ofDecision

    8 Nov 2007 · 62004TJ0234

  • Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union114Law