As a reaction to the trade in empty-shell companies, the German Parliament restricted in 1997 the possibility to carry forward losses, by introducing in § 8(4) KStG the so-called ‘Mantelkaufregelung’ (‘coat-buying rule’, the coat being the empty-shell company). This rule restricted the carrying forward of losses to those corporate entities that were legally and economically identical with the entity that incurred the losses. The rule did not contain a definition of ‘economically identical’, but relied on one negative and two positive elements:
there is no economic identity if more than half of the shares of the corporate entity are transferred and the entity then continues its economic activity or starts it anew, with predominantly new assets,
there is, on the contrary, economic identity if the injection of new assets solely has the purpose of restructuring the loss-making entity and if the activity which had caused the unrelieved loss carry-forward, continues in a comparable manner for the following 5 years,
there is also economic identity if, rather than injecting new assets, the acquiring entity covers the losses that have accrued at the loss-making entity.