The Parties submit that, while it would be difficult to draw a particular distinction
based on aircraft sizes, a possible distinction could be made between small aircraft
12 Form CO, paragraph 59 et seq.
13 See agreed non-confidential minutes of a conference call of 28 June 2019 with a competitor; agreed nonconfidential minutes of a conference call of 8 July 2019 with a competitor; agreed non-confidential minutes of a conference call of 12 July 2019 with a competitor; agreed non-confidential minutes of a conference call of 20 June with a customer; agreed non-confidential minutes of a conference call of 26 June with a customer; agreed non-confidential minutes of a conference call of 1 July with a customer; agreed non-confidential minutes of a conference call of 2 July with a customer.
14 See sections 6.1, 6.3.2, 6.3.5 and 6.3.6 below.
15 Case M.9287 – Connect Airways/Flybe, paragraph 223 (to be published).
16 Reply to RFI 1 of 10 July 2019, question 3.
17 Case M.9287 – Connect Airways/Flybe, paragraph 229 (to be published). with a seat capacity between 30-120 seats, middle-sized aircraft with a seat capacity between 121-190 seats and large aircraft with a seat capacity of more than 191 seats.
Given the various sizes available, it would not be possible to draw a clear line between regional aircraft and slightly larger narrow-body aircraft with more than 100 seats. In the Parties’ view, while aircraft with a seat capacity of below 50 would be distinct from a demand side perspective, the aircraft sizes above would become substitutable to a significant extent. The Parties explained that, from a demand side perspective, airlines would take into account the total cost of production in their consideration which aircraft size to wet lease. These costs would include the wet lease rate charged by the lessor and all other operating cost for the flight operations.
Larger aircraft would have a higher trip cost than a smaller unit, but the cost per seat would be lower and could be more attractive to a lessee.18