52 G. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS AND HEARINGS, Regulation (EU) 2017/1589

In forcesince 19 Sep 2017

Chinaland also claimed that the Commission could not impose duties retroactively without falling foul of the principle of non-retroactivity, having allegedly itself recognised in another case, that there would be no legal basis for such a retroactive withdrawal [Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/1403, recitals 30 to 32.]. Chinaland also cites a previous decision according to which it allegedly deserves like treatment [Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/866, recitals 88 and 89.]. First, it should be noted that all Commission decisions withdrawing the acceptance of an undertaking are taken on a case-by-case basis. Decisions taken within these individual cases are, accordingly, limited and specific to the circumstances at hand, so that a like casting of reasoning therein on a different case cannot be done. In any case, Chinaland has advanced no arguments on how its case resembles that of the exporting producer concerned by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/866. Second, it is true that the activities of the European institutions are subject to the general principles of law, in particular those of legal certainty and non-retroactivity. However, the Commission recalls that settled case-law of the Court of Justice recognises that an economic operator cannot entertain a legitimate expectation that an ‘existing situation’ which is capable of being altered by decisions taken by the Union institutions within the limits of their discretion will be maintained [Judgment of 17 October 1996, Konservenfabrik Lubella v Hauptzollamt Cottbus, C-64/95, EU:1996:388, paragraph 31. See also, more recently, Judgment of 10 December 2015, SIA Veloserviss, Case C-427/14, EU:C:2015:803, at paragraph 39.]. The principle of legitimate expectations does not protect situations in which no legitimate expectations existed, especially where the economic operator was warned from the outset about the consequences of breach of an undertaking through particular transactions. Against this background it becomes obvious that in scenarios where incorrect or incomplete undertaking invoices are presented, the ordinary anti-dumping/countervailing duty otherwise due for the exporting producer in question takes hold as if the latter had not presented an undertaking invoice and that the duties that were not paid as a cause of this presentation of undertaking invoices must become due as if no exemption thereof existed. Third, this type of invalidation of undertaking invoices and related exposure to the duties not paid is not a retroactive imposition of measures within the meaning of European Union law, nor does it fall within Articles 10(5) and 16(5) of the basic anti-dumping and anti-subsidy Regulations. The fact that Chinaland offers no definition of ‘retroactivity’ that would deviate from the established general principle of European Union law recalled by reference to case-law above underscores this. In light of the above reasons, the claims forwarded by Chinaland against the withdrawal of the acceptance of the undertaking are rejected.

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 17 October 1996. Konservenfabrik Lubella Friedrich Büker GmbH & Co. KG v Hauptzollamt Cottbus.Decision

    17 Oct 1996 · 61995CJ0064

  • Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 10 December 2015. Valsts ieņēmumu dienests v "Veloserviss” SIA.Decision

    10 Dec 2015 · 62014CJ0427

  • Regulation (EU) 2015/866Law

  • Regulation (EU) 2015/1403Law

  • celex=31964D0095
  • celex=32013D0707