86 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURES › 5.1. PRESENCE OF STATE AID WITHIN THE MEANING OF ARTICLE 107(1) TFEU › 5.1.4. SELECTIVITY › 5.1.4.1. Assessment of selectivity if Articles 1 and 2 of the CIR constitute the legal basis for the non-payment of corporate tax by the Belgian ports, Decision_act (EU) 2017/2115

In forcesince 27 Jul 2017cited 1×

The Commission notes that the assumption on which the Belgian authorities base their reasoning is in contradiction with the official comments on the CIR, with other domestic texts and with official positions adopted by the Belgian Government. The official comments on the CIR state that legal persons who are ‘unconditionally’ excluded from corporate tax (notably the ports pursuant to Article 180(2) of the CIR) should ‘in principle be regarded as taxpayers subject to corporate tax’ [See comment 179/2: ‘Already now, attention is drawn to the fact that, although they may in principle be regarded as taxpayers subject to corporate tax, the following are excluded from corporate tax on the basis of Articles 180 to 182 of the CIR 92: 1. legal persons who are ‘unconditionally’ excluded from corporate tax (see comment on Article 180 of the CIR 92); […]’.]. Also in view of their legal form (and the characteristics generally associated with this legal form), the majority of the ports listed in Article 180(2) of the CIR – which are public limited companies (SA), private limited companies (SPRL) or autonomous municipal authorities – should also be subject in principle to corporate tax [See comment No 179/16: ‘Belgian commercial companies (SA, SCA, SNC, SCS, SPRL, SC and SCRIS) are in principle constituted to engage in a profit-making activity. As a general rule, they therefore in fact engage in either an industrial, commercial or agricultural business of some kind, or a profit-making occupation, or both at once, and all the profits in general of any kind that they make must be considered as resulting from this activity.’ Also see points A.2.1 and B3.1 of judgment No 148/2012 of the Constitutional Court of 6 December 2012 (Moniteur belge, 29 January 2013). In response to a parliamentary question, the Minister for Finance stated that, as far as the autonomous municipal authorities are concerned, it was necessary to examine on a case-by-case basis whether they were subject to corporate tax or the tax on legal persons, depending on the nature of the activities concerned. Since by virtue of the Royal Decree of 10 April 1995, these activities must be of an industrial or commercial nature, it can be considered, according to the Minister, that the autonomous municipal authorities are in principle subject to corporate tax (QRVA, Lower House, 1996-1997, No 86, 16 June 1997, pp. 11749-11750; QRVA, Lower House 2001-2002, 26 March 2002, CRIV 50 COM 702, pp. 8-9).]. Second, the Flemish Port Decree of 2 March 1999 itself contains indications concerning the industrial [See Article 25(2): ‘The Flemish Government shall be authorised to create a joint concertation commission. A five-year promotion plan, based on an industrial economy model, shall be drawn up.’] and/or commercial nature [See Article 26(1): ‘Disputes between port authorities in operational matters, especially with regard to the commercial activities of the port authorities […] shall be regulated by the port disputes commission […]’.] of the port activities and therefore their classification as ‘company’ within the meaning of Article 2 of the CIR, the consequence of which should be that they are subject to corporate tax. Likewise, the Belgian Government itself argued, before the Belgian Constitutional Court, that the ports, among other companies and legal persons referred to in Articles 180 and 220(2) of the CIR, are ‘in fact legal persons who engage in a business or transactions of a profit-making nature within the meaning of Article 2 of the CIR’ [See Judgment No 136/98 of 16 December 1998 (Moniteur belge of 6 January 1999, p. 261), point A.7.1: ‘According to the Council of Ministers, the companies and legal persons referred to in Article 220(2) of the CIR are in comparable situations. Although Article 180 of the CIR excludes the aforementioned legal persons from corporate tax, they are in fact legal persons who engage in a business or transactions of a profit-making nature within the meaning of Article 2, § 2(1) and (2) of the CIR.’ Also see point A.7.2: ‘An objective criterion exists to distinguish between the legal persons referred to in Article 220(1) and (3), on the one hand, and those referred to in Article 220(2) [namely the ports] on the other hand, in that only the latter category engages in transactions of a profit-making nature. […]’]. Before the Lower House of the Belgian Parliament, the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Finance and Foreign Trade also stated that the Belgian ports were public undertakings which, in the absence of the unconditional exemption provided for in Article 180 of the CIR, would be subject to corporate tax pursuant to Articles 1, 2 and 179 of the CIR [Public meeting of Wednesday 29 January 1997, Finance and Budget Committee, Question by Mr Jacques Simonet to the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Finance and Foreign Trade on the liability of Belgian ports to the tax on legal persons (No 1017). See http://www3.dekamer.be/digidocanha/K0112/K01120466/K01120466.PDF p. 5.]. Finally, the ports are not subject to the tax on legal persons naturally and directly, but only because they are specifically exempted from corporate tax by Article 180(2) of the CIR, according to the actual wording of Article 220(2) of the CIR, which contradicts the Belgian authorities' interpretation that the ports do not pay corporate tax because they are naturally subject to the tax on legal persons, as resident legal persons other than ‘companies’.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Sixth Chamber, Extended Composition) of 20 September 2019. Havenbedrijf Antwerpen NV and Maatschappij van de Decision

    In the first place, in the context of the second assumption, the Commission analysed the Belgian authorities’ argument that Article 180(2) of the CIR merely draws the consequences from the general rules set out in Articles 1 and 2 of the …

    20 Sep 2019 · 62017TJ0696