The majority of interested parties and the Belgian authorities dispute the economic nature of the activities mentioned by the Commission in the opening decision, in particular making the port infrastructure available to shipping and renting land and infrastructure to undertakings. They explain that the tariffs for land rental, infrastructure concessions and access to the port infrastructure (port charges) are public, non-discriminatory and fixed unilaterally in advance by the port authorities and are not determined by the interaction of supply and demand. They mention in particular a judgment by the Belgian Constitutional Court of 19 November 2015 [C.C., 19 November 2015, No 162/2015; Moniteur belge of 5 February 2016; Numac: 2015205632.] recognising that the port charges constitute ‘pure remuneration’, by third parties, for the intervention of the port authorities. They also refer to the Flemish Port Decree of 2 March 1999 on seaport policy and management [Moniteur belge of 8 April 1999; Numac: 1999035415. See Article 13(3): ‘Port charges shall be set autonomously by the port authorities, in reasonable proportion to the value of the consideration received (…)’.] (‘Flemish Port Decree of 2 March 1999’), which provides that port charges must be set in ‘reasonable proportion’ to the value of the consideration received. Moreover, they point out that the concession fees are proportionally lower for the sites generating higher added value, are based on objective parameters (relating to the sites concerned) and reflect the intrinsic value generated by the service provided. Likewise, the Walloon Region and the Walloon ports consider that the payment of charges for the use of the infrastructure does not necessarily point to the economic nature of the port activities, since the fact that these charges do not cover the reconstitution of the capital invested indicates that the port activities are services of general interest.
18 4. COMMENTS RECEIVED AFTER THE INITIATION OF THE FORMAL INVESTIGATION PROCEDURE › 4.1. UNDERTAKINGS/ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES, Decision_act (EU) 2017/2115
In forcesince 27 Jul 2017