Recital 22, Directive (EU) 2016/343

In forcesince 9 Mar 2016cited 8×

The burden of proof for establishing the guilt of suspects and accused persons is on the prosecution, and any doubt should benefit the suspect or accused person. The presumption of innocence would be infringed if the burden of proof were shifted from the prosecution to the defence, without prejudice to any ex officio fact-finding powers of the court, to the independence of the judiciary when assessing the guilt of the suspect or accused person, and to the use of presumptions of fact or law concerning the criminal liability of a suspect or accused person. Such presumptions should be confined within reasonable limits, taking into account the importance of what is at stake and maintaining the rights of the defence, and the means employed should be reasonably proportionate to the legitimate aim pursued. Such presumptions should be rebuttable and in any event, should be used only where the rights of the defence are respected.

  • Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 28 November 2019. Criminal proceedings against Spetsializirana prokuratura.Decision

    However, that court doubts whether the Bulgarian law is compatible with Article 6 and recital 22 of Directive 2016/343, in so far as those provisions could be interpreted as placing the burden of proof as regards the merits of the …

    28 Nov 2019 · 62019CJ0653

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 16 November 2021. Criminal proceedings against WB and Others.Decision

    These requests for a preliminary ruling concern the interpretation of the second subparagraph of Article 19(1) TEU, read in the light of Article 2 TEU, and of Article 6(1) and (2) of Directive (EU) 2016/343 of the European Parliament and …

    16 Nov 2021 · 62019CJ0748

  • Opinion of Advocate General Bobek delivered on 20 May 2021. Criminal proceedings against WB and Others.Decision

    Against that background, and in the light of the alleged links between certain judges sitting on the panels destined to adjudicate in the main proceedings and the Minister for Justice/General Prosecutor, it stands to reason that the …

    20 May 2021 · 62019CC0748

  • Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 8 December 2022. Criminal proceedings against HYA and Others.Decision

    It is true that Article 6(1) of Directive 2016/343, which governs the allocation of the burden of such proof (see, to that effect, the judgment of 28 November 2019, Spetsializirana prokuratura, C‑653/19 PPU, EU:C:2019:1024, paragraph …

    8 Dec 2022 · 62021CJ0348

  • Opinion of Advocate General Bobek delivered on 11 October 2016. Criminal proceedings against Emil Milev.Decision

    According to recitals 16 and 22 of Directive 2016/343: The presumption of innocence would be violated if public statements made by public authorities, or judicial decisions other than those on guilt, referred to a suspect or an accused …

    11 Oct 2016 · 62016CC0439

  • Opinion of Advocate General Collins delivered on 7 July 2022. Criminal proceedings against HYA and Others.Decision

    Recitals 9 to 11, 22, 33 to 35, 47 and 48 of Directive 2016/343 read as follows: The purpose of this Directive is to enhance the right to a fair trial in criminal proceedings by laying down common minimum rules concerning certain aspects …

    7 Jul 2022 · 62021CC0348

  • Opinion of Advocate General Pitruzzella delivered on 19 November 2019. Criminal proceedings against Spetsializirana prokuratura.Decision

    The referring court observes that the Public Prosecutor’s Office did not make any application for the continuation of the detention. The detention continues as long as the defence is unable to show evidence of a change in circumstances …

    19 Nov 2019 · 62019CC0653

  • Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 1 August 2025. Criminal proceedings against KP.Decision

    The referring court is of the view that, in those circumstances, proof of that person’s guilt necessarily lies with the court. Consequently, the referring court is uncertain whether the criminal court may find on its own initiative, in …

    1 Aug 2025 · 62024CJ0404