Art. 11 Directive (EU) 2014/41

Grounds for non-recognition or non-execution

In forcesince 3 Apr 2014cited 22×
1.

Without prejudice to Article 1(4), recognition or execution of an EIO may be refused in the executing State where:

(a)

there is an immunity or a privilege under the law of the executing State which makes it impossible to execute the EIO or there are rules on determination and limitation of criminal liability relating to freedom of the press and freedom of expression in other media, which make it impossible to execute the EIO;

(b)

in a specific case the execution of the EIO would harm essential national security interests, jeopardise the source of the information or involve the use of classified information relating to specific intelligence activities;

(c)

the EIO has been issued in proceedings referred to in Article 4(b) and (c) and the investigative measure would not be authorised under the law of the executing State in a similar domestic case;

(d)

the execution of the EIO would be contrary to the principle of ne bis in idem;

(e)

the EIO relates to a criminal offence which is alleged to have been committed outside the territory of the issuing State and wholly or partially on the territory of the executing State, and the conduct in connection with which the EIO is issued is not an offence in the executing State;

(f)

there are substantial grounds to believe that the execution of the investigative measure indicated in the EIO would be incompatible with the executing State's obligations in accordance with Article 6 TEU and the Charter;

(g)

the conduct for which the EIO has been issued does not constitute an offence under the law of the executing State, unless it concerns an offence listed within the categories of offences set out in Annex D, as indicated by the issuing authority in the EIO, if it is punishable in the issuing State by a custodial sentence or a detention order for a maximum period of at least three years; or

(h)

the use of the investigative measure indicated in the EIO is restricted under the law of the executing State to a list or category of offences or to offences punishable by a certain threshold, which does not include the offence covered by the EIO.

2.

Paragraphs 1(g) and 1(h) do not apply to investigative measures referred to in Article 10(2).

3.

Where the EIO concerns an offence in connection with taxes or duties, customs and exchange, the executing authority shall not refuse recognition or execution on the ground that the law of the executing State does not impose the same kind of tax or duty or does not contain a tax, duty, customs and exchange regulation of the same kind as the law of the issuing State.

4.

In the cases referred to in points (a), (b), (d), (e) and (f) of paragraph 1 before deciding not to recognise or not to execute an EIO, either in whole or in part the executing authority shall consult the issuing authority, by any appropriate means, and shall, where appropriate, request the issuing authority to supply any necessary information without delay.

5.

In the case referred to in paragraph 1(a) and where power to waive the privilege or immunity lies with an authority of the executing State, the executing authority shall request it to exercise that power forthwith. Where power to waive the privilege or immunity lies with an authority of another State or international organisation, it shall be for the issuing authority to request the authority concerned to exercise that power.

The 10 that are cited most themselves, of 22.

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 December 2020. Criminal proceedings against A and Others.Decision

    Article 11 of Directive 2014/41, headed ‘Grounds for non-recognition or non-execution’, lists, in paragraph 1 thereof, the grounds for non-recognition or non-execution of a European investigation order in the executing State. Those …

    8 Dec 2020 · 62019CJ0584

  • Hoge Raad, 21-12-2021, 21/02482Decision

    … artikelen 9 en 11 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU en de preambule onder 11, alsmede artikel 5.4.4 Sv). Het is aan de uitvaardigende staat om te beoordelen of er grond bestaat een EOB uit te vaardigen (vgl. artikel 6 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU). Ook is het …

    21 Dec 2021 · ECLI:NL:HR:2021:1940

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 16 December 2021. Criminal proceedings against HP.Decision

    Article 11 of that directive lists the grounds on which recognition or execution of an EIO may be refused in the executing State.

    16 Dec 2021 · 62019CJ0724

  • Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 11 November 2021. Criminal proceedings against Ivan Gavanozov.Decision

    Furthermore, as is apparent from paragraph 43 of the present judgment, Directive 2014/41 is based on the principle that EIOs are to be executed. Article 11(1)(f) of that directive permits the executing authorities to derogate from that …

    11 Nov 2021 · 62019CJ0852

  • Hoge Raad, 05-04-2022, 21/04283Decision

    … artikelen 9 en 11 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU en de preambule onder 11, alsmede artikel 5.4.4 Sv). Het is aan de uitvaardigende staat om te beoordelen of er grond bestaat een EOB uit te vaardigen (vgl. artikel 6 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU). Ook is het …

    5 Apr 2022 · ECLI:NL:HR:2022:511

  • Opinion of Advocate General Bot delivered on 11 April 2019. Criminal proceedings against Ivan Gavanozov.Decision

    Article 11 of Directive 2014/41, in Chapter III, entitled ‘Procedures and safeguards for the executing State’, provides: ‘1. Without prejudice to Article 1(4), recognition or execution of an EIO may be refused in the executing State …

    11 Apr 2019 · 62017CC0324

  • Opinion of Advocate General Bobek delivered on 19 November 2020. WS v Bundesrepublik Deutschland.Decision

    Pursuant to Article 11(1)(d) of Directive 2014/41, the principle ne bis in idem constitutes one of the grounds for non-recognition or non-execution of an EIO. It should not be overlooked, in this context, that EIOs may also be adopted …

    19 Nov 2020 · 62019CC0505

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 2 September 2021. XK.Decision

    Article 11 of that directive, entitled ‘Grounds for non-recognition or non-execution’, lists, in paragraph 1 thereof, the grounds for non-recognition or non-execution of an EIO in the executing State.

    2 Sep 2021 · 62020CJ0066

  • Opinion of Advocate General Richard de la Tour delivered on 12 June 2025.Decision

    Furthermore, when it was called upon to consider the ground for non-execution of a European Investigation Order, provided for in Article 11(1)(f) of Directive 2014/41/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 3 April 2014 …

    12 Jun 2025 · 62024CC0008

  • Opinion of Advocate General Rantos delivered on 13 February 2025. WBS GmbH v Generalstaatsanwaltschaft Berlin.Decision

    … 1, i direktiv 2014/41, sammenholdt med artikel 2, litra c), og 11. betragtning til dette direktiv, ligesom udstedelsen af en europæisk efterretningskendelse, betinget af opfyldelsen af to kumulative betingelser, nemlig dels i henhold til …

    13 Feb 2025 · 62023CC0635