Art. 10 Directive (EU) 2014/41

Recourse to a different type of investigative measure

In forcesince 3 Apr 2014cited 21×
1.

The executing authority shall have, wherever possible, recourse to an investigative measure other than that provided for in the EIO where:

(a)

the investigative measure indicated in the EIO does not exist under the law of the executing State; or

(b)

the investigative measure indicated in the EIO would not be available in a similar domestic case.

2.

Without prejudice to Article 11, paragraph (1) does not apply to the following investigative measures, which always have to be available under the law of the executing State:

(a)

the obtaining of information or evidence which is already in the possession of the executing authority and the information or evidence could have been obtained, in accordance with the law of the executing State, in the framework of criminal proceedings or for the purposes of the EIO;

(b)

the obtaining of information contained in databases held by police or judicial authorities and directly accessible by the executing authority in the framework of criminal proceedings;

(c)

the hearing of a witness, expert, victim, suspected or accused person or third party in the territory of the executing State;

(d)

any non-coercive investigative measure as defined under the law of the executing State;

(e)

the identification of persons holding a subscription of a specified phone number or IP address.

3.

The executing authority may also have recourse to an investigative measure other than that indicated in the EIO where the investigative measure selected by the executing authority would achieve the same result by less intrusive means than the investigative measure indicated in the EIO.

4.

When the executing authority decides to avail itself of the possibility referred to in paragraphs 1 and 3, it shall first inform the issuing authority, which may decide to withdraw or supplement the EIO.

5.

Where, in accordance with paragraph 1, the investigative measure indicated in the EIO does not exist under the law of the executing State or it would not be available in a similar domestic case and where there is no other investigative measure which would have the same result as the investigative measure requested, the executing authority shall notify the issuing authority that it has not been possible to provide the assistance requested.

The 10 that are cited most themselves, of 21.

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 8 December 2020. Criminal proceedings against A and Others.Decision

    Article 10 of that directive, headed ‘Recourse to a different type of investigative measure’, provides, in paragraphs 1, 3 and 4 thereof: ‘1. The executing authority shall have, wherever possible, recourse to an investigative measure …

    8 Dec 2020 · 62019CJ0584

  • Hoge Raad, 21-12-2021, 21/02482Decision

    … onder meer artikel 10 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU). De materiële gronden voor het uitvaardigen van het EOB kunnen alleen in de uitvaardigende staat worden aangevochten (artikel 14 lid 2 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU).

    21 Dec 2021 · ECLI:NL:HR:2021:1940

  • Hoge Raad, 05-04-2022, 21/04283Decision

    … onder meer artikel 10 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU). De materiële gronden voor het uitvaardigen van het EOB kunnen alleen in de uitvaardigende staat worden aangevochten (artikel 14 lid 2 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU). > 4.2.2 De betrokkene bij wie ter …

    5 Apr 2022 · ECLI:NL:HR:2022:511

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 9 January 2025. AK.Decision

    Thus, first of all, Article 10(2), like Articles 24 to 31 of Directive 2014/41, sets out a series of investigative measures which are all aimed at obtaining evidence to establish the facts or the identity of the perpetrator.

    9 Jan 2025 · 62023CJ0583

  • Hoge Raad, 13-06-2023, 23/00011, 23/00010Decision

    … onder meer artikel 10 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU). De materiële gronden voor het uitvaardigen van het EOB kunnen alleen in de uitvaardigende lidstaat worden aangevochten (vgl. artikel 14 lid 2 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU).

    13 Jun 2023 · ECLI:NL:HR:2023:913

  • Opinion of Advocate General Campos Sánchez-Bordona delivered on 16 July 2020. Criminal proceedings against A and Others.Decision

    An EIO is defined as a judicial decision which has been issued or validated by a judicial authority of a Member State (‘the issuing State’) to have one or several specific investigative measure(s) carried out in another Member State …

    16 Jul 2020 · 62019CC0584

  • Opinion of Advocate General Collins delivered on 4 October 2024. AK.Decision

    Directive 2014/41 does not contain a definition of the concept of an ‘investigative measure’ or provide for a list of measures that an authority may request be carried out by means of a European Investigation Order. It is true that, in …

    4 Oct 2024 · 62023CC0583

  • Hoge Raad, 14-04-2026, 24/02527Decision

    … artikel 9 lid 2 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU). Bij de uitvoering van het EOB is het de uitvoerende lidstaat onder de in artikel 10 Richtlijn 2014/41/EU omschreven voorwaarden toegestaan een andere dan de in het EOB genoemde onderzoeksmaatregel toe …

    14 Apr 2026 · ECLI:NL:HR:2026:650

  • A.L. ET E.J. c. FRANCEDecision

    … Par ailleurs, elle a relevé que l’article 10 de la directive 2014/41 permet à l’autorité d’exécution de recourir à une autre mesure d’enquête que celle indiquée dans la DEE si cette mesure alternative permet d’obtenir le …

    24 Sep 2024 · 001-237767

  • Opinion of Advocate General Ćapeta delivered on 22 June 2023. Criminal proceedings against G.K. and Others.Decision

    An assessment that a less intrusive measure would achieve the same result corresponds to Article 10(3) of the EIO Directive, under which the executing authority may change the measure requested by an EIO. More importantly, this means that …

    22 Jun 2023 · 62022CC0281