The measure in question entails a transfer of State resources to certain undertakings. Although the concept of an undertaking is not defined by the Treaty, it refers to any natural or legal person, regardless of its legal status and its financing, who carries out an economic activity. In Commission practice, as confirmed by the Courts, operation of television transmission networks is considered to be an economic activity [Commission decisions N622/2003 Digitalisierungsfonds Austria, C25/2004 DVB-T Berlin Brandenburg (paragraph 62), C34/2006 DVB-T North-Rhine Westphalia (paragraph 83), C52/2005 Mediaset (paragraph 96).], similarly to other cases involving management of infrastructure by the regional authorities [Case T-196/04 Ryanair Ltd v European Commission, [2007] ECR II-2379, paragraph 88, Case C-82/01P Aéroports de Paris v Commission, [2002] ECR I-9297, paragraphs 107-109 and 121-125.]. In the case at hand, most of the public undertakings or town councils are registered in the register of the CMT as network operators. This suggests that they provide certain services, which according to settled case practice constitutes an economic activity. A market exists if other operators would be willing or able to provide the service in question, which is the case. For instance Astra held several meetings with the Autonomous Communities before the implementation of the extension of the coverage in Area II to present them its offer. In addition, in March 2008 Astra participated in and won a technologically neutral tender for providing digital TV in Area II and Area III published in Cantabria. The fact that the public undertakings and town councils do not receive remuneration for the services provided does not preclude the activities in question from being considered to be an economic activity [See Joined Cases T-443/08 and T-455/08, Freistaat Sachsen and Land Sachsen-Anhalt (T-443/08) and Mitteldeutsche Flughafen AG and Flughafen Leipzig-Halle GmbH (T-455/08) v European Commission [2011] ECR II-01311, paragraph 115, where the Court states: ‘The fact that an activity is not engaged in by private operators or that it is unprofitable are irrelevant criteria in regard to the classification of that activity as an economic activity (…).’].
97 5. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 5.2. STATE AID ASSESSMENT PURSUANT TO ARTICLE 107(1) TFEU › 5.2.1. Presence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › 5.2.1.2. Economic advantage to entities carrying out an economic activity, Decision_act (EU) 2014/489
Judgment of the General Court (Fifth Chamber) of 26 November 2015. Kingdom of Spain v European Commission.Decision
Second, as regards the Kingdom of Spain’s argument that there was no market for the service designed to ensure the right of every person to receive televisual communication, it should be observed that, as the Commission points out in …
26 Nov 2015 · 62013TJ0461
Judgment of the General Court (Eighth Chamber) of 24 March 2011. Freistaat Sachsen and Land Sachsen-Anhalt (T-443/08) and Mitteldeutsche FluDecision
24 Mar 2011 · 62008TJ0443
Judgment of the Court (Sixth Chamber) of 24 October 2002. Aéroports de Paris v Commission of the European Communities.Decision
24 Oct 2002 · 62001CJ0082
Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Eighth Chamber, extended composition) of 17 December 2008. Ryanair Ltd v Commission of the EuropeanDecision
17 Dec 2008 · 62004TJ0196
- celex=31982D0001