42 3. COMMENTS FROM SPAIN › 3.1. GENERAL REMARKS, Decision_act (EU) 2014/489

In forcesince 19 Jun 2013

In its defence to the opening decision, Spain and the Autonomous Communities have put forward numerous arguments [The arguments of the central and regional authorities are presented together as the position of Spain (or of the Spanish authorities), except for the Basque Country, which requested the application of public service compensation rules.]. Broadly speaking they fall into two categories. First, the Spanish authorities argue that there is no state aid involved, because as the service is an SGEI the measure does not constitute aid, as it falls under the public service remit of public broadcasting. Moreover, it does not generate any advantage. Secondly, even if there was any state aid, it would be compatible under Article 106(2) or Article 107(3)(c) given that (a) the analogue network already existed and, from an efficiency perspective, a mere upgrade of the existing infrastructure would be less costly than switching to a new platform; (b) only the DTT technology would fulfil the necessary quality criteria and (c) the tenders were technologically neutral and other platform operators could have participated in the tendering. These arguments are summarised below.