9 2. DESCRIPTION OF THE MEASURE › 2.1. BACKGROUND › 2.1.1. Complainant, Decision_act (EU) 2014/489

In forcesince 19 Jun 2013

In its complaint, Astra alleges that the measures put in place by the Government and the Autonomous Communities in remote and less urbanised areas of Spain infringe the principle of technological neutrality, as they envisage terrestrial transmission as the only route towards digitisation. Astra refers in particular to the case of Cantabria. On the basis of a tender for extension of coverage of digital television for the whole territory of Cantabria launched in January 2008, the regional government of Cantabria had selected Astra to provide free-to-air channels via its platform. However, in November 2008 that contract was terminated by the regional government. According to Astra, the authorities only terminated the contract once they had been informed that the central government would finance the upgrade of the analogue terrestrial network. In fact, a letter from the Cantabrian authorities dated 7 November 2008 explained that the reason for the termination of the contract was that in the meantime the central government had taken decisions relating to the extension of coverage of digital television to the whole of Spain [Astra challenged the termination of the contract before a court of first instance in Santander (procedure No 1728/2009), which on 23 December 2011 ordered the Cantabrian authorities to indemnify Astra for the unjustified termination of the contract. The Court did not find any breach of contract on the part of Astra that would justify the termination of the contract. According to the Court, the decision of the Spanish central government to develop the national strategy for DTT was one of the reasons for the termination of the contract. See judgment 000313/2011 of the Court of First Instance of Santander.]. Thus, the case of Cantabria would appear to demonstrate that, firstly, Astra could compete in that market and, secondly, that the decisions of the central government made this competition impossible.