155 5. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 5.3. COMPATIBILITY ASSESSMENT › 5.3.3. Article 107(3)(c) TFEU › 5.3.3.2. Well-defined aid › Technological neutrality, appropriateness and proportionality of the measure, Decision_act (EU) 2014/489

In forcesince 19 Jun 2013cited 3×

As pointed out in section 2.2, the vast majority of tenders have not been technologically neutral, since they refer, either explicitly through the definition of the object of the tender or implicitly in the description of the technical specifications, to terrestrial technology and DTT. Only DTT operators could fulfil these requirements (and only such operators have in fact participated in these tenders).Spain argues that references in the tender to DTT, or specifications referring to DTT equipment and transmission centres, do not mean that the use of such centres was compulsory for the bidders. These references cannot reasonably be interpreted as indicated by Spain. In any case, even if this were the right interpretation, such a formal argument ignores the commercial reality. Participating in tenders is resource intensive and therefore costly for any bidder. Splitting up the intervention in Area II in several hundred individual tenders has multiplied the costs, which amount to a significant entry barrier to any bidder wishing to cover the entire Area II. The combination of central government interventions in favour of DTT technology, as explained in paragraphs 88 and 89, specific tender references to DTT and the need to enter into hundreds of different tender procedures therefore sent a strong signal to other platform operators that participating in such tenders would not be commercially justified. It is therefore concluded that these references in the vast majority of cases made it impossible for operators of other platforms to compete [Although in the technologically neutral initial tender of Cantabria three consortia put in a bid which was built on a satellite solution (Castilla-La-Mancha Telecom, Telefónica and Astra), none of these companies — or any other non-DTT platform operator — participated again in any of the subsequent tenders.].

  • Judgment of the General Court (Fifth Chamber) of 26 November 2015. Kingdom of Spain v European Commission.Decision

    In the present case, it is apparent from recitals 148 to 171 of the contested decision that the Commission considered that the aid at issue could not be regarded as comparable with the internal market pursuant to Article 107(3)(c) TFEU …

    26 Nov 2015 · 62013TJ0461

  • Judgment of the Court (Fourth Chamber) of 20 December 2017. Kingdom of Spain v European Commission.Decision

    Moreover, the Kingdom of Spain’s argument can be summarised as contesting the assertion, in paragraph 104 of the judgment under appeal, that the Commission was not required to provide more details as regards the non-compliance with the …

    20 Dec 2017 · 62016CJ0081

  • Opinion of Advocate General Wathelet delivered on 7 September 2017. Comunidad Autónoma del País Vasco and Others v European Commission.Decision

    SES Astra contends, in essence, for the same reasons as those put forward by the Commission, that this part of the fourth plea is manifestly inadmissible. In addition, in the event that the Court should decide that the SGEI at issue was …

    7 Sep 2017 · 62016CC0066