The Polish authorities summarised that, on the basis of the various valuations, the total value of collateral on the loan was situated somewhere between PLN […] million and PLN […] million (see table 5). For the purpose of its internal rating, IDA had assessed Crist’s collateral to be moderate (see table 3). Referring to the Reference Rate Communication rules (see table 6), the Polish authorities submitted that the total value of the collateral, in line with the market value, is PLN […]million [Crist shares income-based valuation method (recommended by an expert) at PLN […] million and mortgage on the real estate (part of Shipyard Area 2) estimated by an expert at PLN 169,5 million.] and constitutes […] % of the loan granted. This level of collateral significantly exceeds the level of the amount of the loan and corresponds to the category of “high collateralisation”, as defined in the Reference Rate Communication, since the expected loss resulting from default in the loan repayment (LGD) equals 0.
Table 5
The values of the collaterals depending on the adopted methods of valuation
Collateral object and method of valuation
Crist shares
Assets-based valuation method
(Adjusted Net Assets Method)
Crist shares
Income-based valuation method
(Adjusted present Value)
Value (PLN) | […] | […]
Collateral object and method of valuation | Shipyard Area 2 | 169471000 | TOTAL: | TOTAL:
Market value method (income based) | […] | […]
Shipyard Area 2 | 84735500 | TOTAL: | TOTAL:
Forced value sales | […] | […]
Shipyard Area 2 | 180439000 | TOTAL: | TOTAL:
Market value method (income based) | […] | […]
Shipyard Area 2 | 166000000 | TOTAL: | TOTAL:
Value of the last counter-offer | […] | […]