As regards the collateral, the Commission’s assessment focused on whether the expert valuations were done in a conservative manner such that a private investor would have accepted the collateral on offer. In this respect, the Commission observes that, depending on the method used, the valuations of Crist’s shares differ significantly (see recital 40). The Commission also notes the criticism by […] as regards the net asset value valuation of PLN […] million, which omits a number of important factors (see recital 45), which in turn result in the underestimation of the value of Crist equity. Finally, the Commission observes that the valuations of both […] and […] using the APV method arrive at the same conclusion (i.e. valuation of ca. PLN […]million) and that both independent experts are of the opinion that that method should be considered as more representative. In addition to providing these valuations to the Commission, Poland proposed to take as a proxy for the value of the collateral on the dry dock, the value of the counter offer by Patia of PLN 166 million, made at the time of the third tender. The Commission notes that such a proxy does appear to represents the value which a competitor of Crist was ready to pay for the dry dock in a situation of the forced sale of that asset.
73 V. ASSESSMENT › 1. Existence of State aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › 1.1. Existence of an advantage › The interest rate, Decision_act (EU) 2013/9
In forcesince 25 Jul 2012