The forestry sector in Liberia is in a process of recovery and redevelopment following the lifting of the UN sanctions against logging in 2006. The new legislative framework is in place and areas of forest have been identified for conservation and for commercial and community forest operations. New regulations are being developed to regulate the informal sector, known as ‘chainsaw logging’, which supplies mainly the domestic market.
A review of the capacity of government services, private-sector operators and civil society to perform functions prescribed in the new legal and policy frameworks, carried out in December 2010 in preparation for the Voluntary Partnership Agreement (VPA), points to a large gap between the intended functions and the actual capacity. Effective operation of the legality assurance system (LAS) described in this Agreement will require strengthened capacity for core regulatory functions alongside the upgrading of systems described in Annex II.
Liberia will take a range of supporting measures, as indicated in Article 15(1) of this Agreement, in cooperation with the Member States of the Union, the European Commission and other development partners in order to implement this Agreement effectively. These include measures to:
establish implementing structures to ensure effective coordination;
build capacity of key stakeholders;
establish the legality assurance system;
strengthen the legal and regulatory framework;
monitor domestic trade in timber and its importance to the national economy;
monitor the impact of the VPA, including on communities and private-sector operators;
monitor implementation of the VPA;
communicate with national and international stakeholders;
update the strategic framework for the forest sector.
Possible supporting measures are outlined below. These will be further developed into detailed action plans, including investment schedules, at an early stage of implementation of the VPA.
Institutional structures will be established to enable smooth operation and coordination between government and non-government bodies involved in implementing the VPA. In particular, drawing on existing structures two new departments will be created within the Forestry Development Authority (FDA), the Liberia Verification Department (LVD) and the Liberia Licensing Department (LLD). A mechanism for coordination between government agencies and increasing capacity in existing departments to take on new functions will be one priority for the first year. In particular, a structure to manage the outsourced verification/chain of custody system (COCS) contract will be established in the first year of implementation. In preparation for implementation, technical support to plan for and build capacity needed will be a priority (e.g. staff job descriptions, recruitment, engagement of experts and inter-agency communications between the FDA and other line agencies e.g. the Environmental Protection Agency and the Ministries of Commerce and Industry, Labour, Agriculture and Finance (Bureau of Concessions and Bureau of Customs)).
Capacity-building will be required for all parties involved in implementing the VPA. Planning for this should take into consideration on-going and planned sector support, as indicated in Article 15 of this Agreement. Capacity-building encompasses: (a) technical training for government agencies, in particular the FDA, the Environmental Protection Agency and Customs; (b) training for FDA staff working with the external service provider; (c) training for civil society groups to enable them to monitor LAS operations and help communities to participate in forestry-related action; (d) assistance for chainsaw loggers’ groups in cooperative formation and technical skills; (e) training in information management for the LAS and capacity routinely to analyse and publish information on the sector; and (f) increased capacity with the aid of technology, including provision of adequate equipment, software and communication equipment.
In order to guide the significant capacity-building task and drawing on the capacity gap analysis carried out in December 2010, Liberia will develop a comprehensive costed five-year training plan, reflecting ongoing or planned initiatives, differentiating between on-the-job training by the verification/COCS service provider and other training required and identifying training that can be covered by existing initiatives and that for which additional training tailored to VPA requirements is needed.
Furthermore, Liberia will develop a five-year investment plan, identifying the needed equipment and its operating costs, facility construction or refurbishment and maintenance, investments that will be procured by the service provider for eventual handover, those procured under existing funded initiatives and those which will need additional funding. As indicated in Article 15 of this Agreement, the Parties will work together under existing arrangements to secure the resources needed for this capacity-building.
Detailed budgets for all the measures described in this Annex will need to be developed and financing arranged. The latter will include determining the contribution that Liberia can provide from its own resources, establishing what will be required from donors and identifying and engaging potential donors. Key measures may include:
establishing the financial delivery mechanism;
developing a comprehensive short-term and long-term budget and detailed proposals and sources for funding implementation of the VPA;
identifying support from Liberia’s resources and support needed from the Union and other development partners, including coordination of existing donor support where relevant;
securing funds.
The LAS will build on existing systems and structures already operating in Liberia. Support is required to upgrade systems to ensure verification of compliance with the legality definition referred to in Annex II, by means of the procedures outlined in that Annex. The supporting measures will focus on action needed to establish the functional capacity across a number of different government agencies and on introducing independent audit. They involve establishing the legality verification function, the FLEGT licensing system and the independent audit function, and upgrading the existing COCS to meet LAS requirements.
Liberia will contract an external service provider to build, operate, and transfer the legality verification and COCS over a five-year period. A central part of the task will be building the capacity of line government agencies to deliver the functions needed. The external service provider will work directly with staff of the FDA seconded into their service who, in the long run, will become the LVD. Key measures may include:
engage a qualified client’s representative to assist with drawing up detailed specifications and contract documents for the service provider and with selection procedures;
advertising for receiving, shortlisting and evaluating proposals for the service provider;
negotiating a contract with the service provider on a build-operate-transfer basis;
transferring relevant FDA staff to the service provider;
establishing an oversight structure to monitor the service provider;
building and operating the LAS described in Annex II to this Agreement;
integrating mill processes and production of rubber-wood chips into the COCS;
integrate imported timber and confiscated timber into COCS;
extending the LAS to include timber produced for the domestic market;
transferring systems operated by the service provider to the FDA.
The FDA will establish a Licensing Department that will be responsible for FLEGT licensing all exports. It will develop the detailed procedures for FLEGT licensing and ensure coherence with export procedures, phasing out the current system of export permits as the FLEGT licensing system becomes operational. To this end, key measures may include:
with expert assistance as appropriate, developing additional routines to adjust the current export permit system for FLEGT licensing;
establishing the Department within the FDA;
recruiting staff and a technical advisor;
drafting regulations on export licensing;
phasing out export permits;
issuing FLEGT licences;
establishing mechanisms for communication with Union competent authorities.
As indicated in Annex V, Liberia will contract an independent auditor (IA) to ensure smooth operation of the LAS and to lend credibility to the systems, for international markets in particular. Liberia will contract the IA in consultation with the Union following Liberia’s procurement procedures and following the guidance established in Annex V. To this end, key actions may include:
advertising for, short-listing, selecting and negotiating with IA;
developing detailed procedures for the Independent Audit to be agreed with the Joint Implementation Committee (JIC);
initiating independent audits;
establishing capacity for reviewing and reporting.
As indicated in Annex VI, the LAS will be subject to an independent technical evaluation before the licensing scheme becomes fully operational and before the Union authorities will accept FLEGT licenses. Key measures may include:
conducting an independent evaluation of the LAS, reviewing results and adjusting systems if necessary;
informing the JIC of evaluation results and agreeing on a date when the licensing scheme will ‘go live’ and the Union authorities will be required to verify FLEGT licenses before entry to the Union market.
Parallel to implementation of the LAS, Liberia will examine the efficiency of the regulatory and enforcement system and the coherence of the legal framework applicable to the forestry sector and introduce improvements where necessary. Development of the legality definition and the consultations and field testing that took place during its development have brought to light some areas of the regulations that need further amendment to provide clear guidance to economic operators. Key measures may include:
providing for a regulatory review after five years of implementation of the LAS that will allow time to identify practical concerns in application and verification of legal compliance;
improving the following areas of the legal framework; guidelines for negotiation of Social Agreements; community forestry regulations; procedures for handling abandoned logs; procedures for handling timber confiscated due to violation of the law; guidelines on how independent certification schemes will be integrated into the LAS; procedures for producing the debarment list; procedures for tracking timber through processing facilities; regulations on third-party access and use of resources in a concession area; regulation of chainsaw logging; regulations for timber import and timber in transit; improvement of EIA processes and environmental management within timber contract areas;
strengthening the regulations on the safety and welfare of workers involved in the logging industry;
any necessary readjusting of the legality verification matrix described in Annex II as a result of changes to laws and regulations.
The domestic market for timber is very important for the national economy, but poorly understood and largely unregulated. Liberia will adopt new regulations, to help it work with small-scale chainsaw operators. Production for the domestic trade will be integrated into the LAS and regulatory measures will be adopted to ensure better regulation, fair trade and environmental safeguards in what is currently an informal sector operating outside the regulatory system. Key measures may include:
organising of the domestic timber market;
improving of the legal framework relating to the domestic timber market;
establishing an information system;
establishing a suitable traceability system for timber sold on the domestic market;
integrating domestic timber sales into the LAS.
Monitoring the social, environmental and market impact of the VPA, in general and with particular emphasis on forest-dependent communities is necessary to ensure that the VPA is delivering its intended aims. To this end, key measure may include: designing a monitoring framework, including baselines and agreed indicators covering elements such as improvements in governance structures, allocation of forest use right, social agreements and benefit-sharing with affected communities, volumes of regulated timber compared with volumes still unregulated, evidence of law enforcement, volumes of timber confiscated and its disposal, efficiency of revenue capture, efficiency of revenue disbursement to affected communities, markets for Liberia’s timber and the impact of the VPA impact on its competitiveness. The JIC will establish effective monitoring as indicated in Annex X.
The JIC will have overall responsibility for monitoring implementation of the VPA. This will include review and action in response to the Independent Audit reports, and reviews of the impact monitoring described above. In addition, other stakeholders including civil society will monitor implementation of the VPA and, in so doing, contribute to effective implementation of the LAS. The JIC will receive reports from stakeholders and ensure that an effective complaints mechanism is in place for addressing problems identified. Key measures may include:
supporting the national multi-stakeholder monitoring committee described in Article 16 to this Agreement in holding regular open public consultations on implementation of the VPA, where stakeholders will be able to give feedback;
monitoring by civil society, including ensuring that community-level concerns are articulated and communicated to the LVD, LLD and IA, the national multi-stakeholder monitoring committee and to the JIC.
Communication supports implementation of the VPA and is essential to redress the negative image of the sector given the difficult historical background of Liberia and its timber industry. The VPA is an opportunity to work towards transparency, accountability and legality. The value of communicating about the government efforts to improve governance in the forest sector cannot be overemphasised. The VPA will affect not only the administration, but also different stakeholder groups and the broader public and therefore requires a comprehensive communication strategy that will provide all the necessary information on the VPA, its impact and its benefits, not only in economic, but also environmental and social terms. Communication on action planned and achievements under the VPA will aim to:
encourage involvement and guarantee the coherence of actions by various stakeholders;
ensure public access to information to facilitate monitoring;
promote the image of Liberian timber on the international market;
secure public support for the action taken by Liberia to promote sustainable forest resource management and development of the communities that depend on it; and
promote the benefits of a VPA among the stakeholders and the wider public.
To this end, Liberia will support measures to ensure effective communication of the ambition and results of the VPA. Key measures may include:
preparing and implementing a communication strategy with the goal of raising public awareness via modern and traditional media to keep the public and the timber trade informed about implementation of the VPA and its impact and benefits;
identifying appropriate target groups and designing specific printed and electronic messages concerning the VPA for each target audiences with regular updates;
establishing an information exchange platform for consistent dissemination of information to domestic and international partners, including considering where it should be located in the overall implementing structure;
organising trade shows involving prospective trading partners to promote the benefits of FLEGT-licensed timber;
putting systems in place for the appropriate government authorities to publish information and to respond to requests for information under the Freedom of Information Act, as indicated in Annex IX.