The legality definition set out below has been developed through a participatory process with a wide range of stakeholders. During development of the legality definition, Liberian stakeholders identified a number of ambiguities, gaps and inconsistencies in the existing laws, regulations and policies that underlie the legality definition, which need to be addressed in order to achieve the good governance desired in the Liberian forestry sector. The Government of Liberia therefore plans to carry out legal and policy reforms in respect of the forestry sector in consultation with all relevant stakeholders. It is expected that such legal reforms would be completed by 2013, and that the legality definition will be updated thereafter to reflect these amendments. Areas that require policy and legal reforms include:
Social Agreements: Establishment of procedures to govern negotiations of Social Agreements, including (i) timing of negotiations; (ii) timeliness of both the payments and transfers of funds to communities; (iii) minimum content of social agreements and enforcement of provisions; (iv) community user rights in respect of concession areas, and (v) employment of non-skilled workers, etc;
Promulgation of Community forestry regulation to provide specific guidelines for community forest management;
Use of abandoned logs including procedures for their auction, registration of legal ownership and entry into the LAS;
Use of logs confiscated by the Government on grounds of being harvested in violation of the law;
Integration of Independent Certification Schemes into the LAS: discussion and agreement with stakeholders on the use of independent certification scheme(s) in Liberia and identification of the independent certification scheme(s) Liberia would recognize for the purpose of establishing the legal origin of logs imported from non-VPA countries;
Debarment List: The establishment of a debarment list identifying those individuals who contributed to the civil war of Liberia and are thus banned from working in the forest sector, as required by existing FDA Regulations;
Processing facilities: A regulation relating to (i) the establishment of processing facilities by holders of FMCs, and (ii) guidelines on operation of processing facilities;
Third Party Access and Use of Forest Products: Regulations on third party access and use of forest resources in another parties’ concession area;
Validation and promulgation of Chainsaw Regulations: to guide new procedures for working with the informal sector.
In determining whether timber and or timber products being sold on the Liberian market or being exported from Liberia meet the legal standard set out in the definition of ‘legal timber’, the principles and indicators as well as the detailed verification procedures as set out in the following table shall apply. The table describes the format of the Legality Matrix (Principles, Indicators, Verifiers, and Verification Guidance). The matrix is divided into 11 principles, with indicators and verifiers listed underneath each principle, and verification guidance outlining how the indicators should be checked for compliance. The verification guidance (indicating Objective, Regulatory Control, Verification Method, and Frequency) reflects current thinking but may be subject to change during further development of systems and procedures.
The Legality Principle | The Liberian legality definition is divided into 11 legality principles. Each legality principle consists of a number of legality indicators with verifiers under each indicator. A verification procedure has been developed for each indicator.
Legality Indicators | This outlines the norm or requirement the Liberian Verification Department (LVD) needs to check for compliance with the specific legality principle.
Legality Verifiers | Verifiers are evidence the LVD inspectors/or assessors will look for when evaluating if the specific norm or indicator has been met. This list is not exhaustive and the assessor may use additional means of verifying the relevant indicator if required.
Verification Guidance |
These principles guide LVD inspectors/or assessors in their evaluation of a particular indicator:
Objective: The objective puts forward the purpose of the verification procedure.
Regulatory Control: Provides for the normative and/or regulatory requirements in respect of a particular indicator and responsible government bodies.
Verification Method: Provides for description and method of verification and will consist of document review, field inspection, confirmation and/or consultation.
Frequency: Provides for the verification frequency of the indicator or certain aspects thereof by the LVD.
[Cycle: 5 years for FMC & FUP; 3 years for TSC.]
PRINCIPLE 1: LEGAL EXISTENCE/RECOGNITION AND ELIGIBILITY TO OPERATE IN FORESTRY SECTOR
The forest contract or permit holder is a legally recognized business, community or an individual eligible to operate in the forestry sector
Indicator 1.1 The Contract or permit holder is a natural or legal person duly registered with the Government of Liberia and/or recognized by the FDA
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
1.1.1. For corporations and partnerships, current annual Business Registration certificate and license issued by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry (MOCI)
All contract or permit types whose holder is a registered business
1.1.2. For corporate entities, articles of incorporation filed with Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA)
All contract or permit types whose holder is a corporation.
1.1.3. For holders who are not registered businesses, a certificate or letter of recognition issued by FDA
FMC/TSC under Community Forestry law, FUP/PUP, and chain saw permits issued to natural person or sole proprietorship
Verification Guidance | Verification method | Verification frequency
The objective of this procedure is to verify that a person seeking a forest contract or permit for harvesting, processing or exporting logs or any timber product in Liberia is either a duly registered business enterprise or one recognized by FDA as capable of obtaining and holding a forest contract or permit under Liberian law.
Liberian law requires that any person conducting and/or carrying out business must register the business with the MOCI. It is an offence not to register a business. To engage in community forestry the community must be recognized by the FDA. Business registration expires annually on the date of registration and must be renewed. The NFRL also provides that any eligible person may obtain and hold a forest contract. The term ‘person’ is defined to include both natural and legal person, and incorporated and unincorporated entities.
The existence of a valid business registration document is verified by the LVD. In the event that clarity is required the LVD can obtain additional information from the MOCI and the FDA Commercial and Legal Departments. In case of community forestry, verification of FDA’s recognition of the community may be obtained from the FDA Legal and Community Forestry Department.
Document review
Consultation with MOCI and the FDA Commercial, Legal and Community Forestry Departments
Annually
References: GBL (4.3 to 4.5); COCS SOP(4) |
Indicator 1.2 The current owner(s) or shareholders of a contract or permit holder do not include the current President and the Vice President of Liberia, Members of the Legislature, Members of the cabinet, Directors and Managers of FDA, current county Superintendents or any other person specifically prohibited from owning a forest contractor or an interest in a forest contract
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
1.2.1 For a contract holder that is a registered business, a notarized affidavit executed by its CEO declaring that its owners do not include prohibited persons
All contract and permit types
1.2.2 Current FDA-prepared list of current senior Government officials prohibited from holding forest license pursuant to Section 5.2(b) of NFRL
All contract and permit types
1.2.3 Current List of shareholders and beneficial owners of corporate contract or permit holder
All contract and permit types
Verification Guidance/ Procedure (LAS-LVD-0.1.2) | Verification Method | Verification frequency
The objective of this procedure is to ensure that all applicants for forest licensing and/or concessions are eligible to hold a forest license.
Holders of certain positions in Government are prohibited by Section 5.2b of the NFRL to conduct commercial forest operations because of actual or potential conflict of interest. A key regulatory interest is to cross check the current owner of a contract holder against the current list of prohibited senior government officials maintained by the FDA. Because the primary responsibility is on the contract holder to ensure that its owners are eligible persons, the contract holder is to execute an affidavit that it is in compliance.
The veracity of the sworn affidavit will be checked against available records regarding the owners of the contract holder. The list of prohibited persons as well as the list of current shareholders of registered businesses holding contract or licenses shall be placed in the public domain, as is stated under Annex IX of this Agreement.
In order to ensure that the above requirements have been met, the LVD must review the ownership records of the contract holder to verify that the applicant is not a prohibited person or an entity whose owner(s) include prohibited person(s).
Consultation with the FDA
Document review
Per shipment
References: NFRL (5.2b); Regulation 103-7(21-22) Regulation 104-07(62); Sections 44, PPC Act |
Indicator 1.3 The Contract holder is not barred from bidding or applying for a forest license or any other government contract/concession because of violations of the Public Procurement and Concessions Act (PPCA)
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
1.3.1 Public Procurement Concession Commission (PPCC) develops and maintains a Debarment List of persons found guilty of violating the PPC Act and or the rules and guidelines established thereunder
FMC, TSC and FUP having value of more than US $ 10000,00
Verification Guidance/ Procedure: | Verification Method | Verification Frequency
The objective of this procedure is to ensure that all applicants for forest contracts or permits are not in violation of the PPC Act governing award of concessions and other contracts.
An applicant for forest licensing must not be barred from bidding for concession and other public contracts due to violations of tender rules established by the PPCC. Successful bidders must be checked against the current/updated debarment list that is produced and maintained by the PPCC under section 44 of the PPC Act, which precludes certain entities from being awarded a concession as a result of certain conditions being present after a successful application and/or bid.
In order to ensure the above requirements have been met, the LVD must verify that the applicant is not on the PPCC debarment list. The PPCC debarment list shall be one of the documents placed in the public domain as indicated in Annex IX of this Agreement.
Consultation with PPCC
Document review
Once during the contract period
References: Sections 44, PPC Act |
PRINCIPLE 2: FOREST ALLOCATION
The Forest Use Rights covered by the contract was awarded pursuant to the National Forestry Reform Law and the Community Rights Law
Indicator 2.1 All communities within 3,0 kilometres of the proposed concession area (called ‘affected communities’) have been consulted by FDA and have given their informed consent to the proposed concession
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
2.1.1 FDA-prepared socio-economic survey report
FMC, TSC, and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000,00
2.1.2 Written notices of the consultation meeting(s) (Radio or Newspaper announcements)
FMC, TSC, and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000,00
2.1.3 Minutes and attendance list of the meetings showing key points discussed and agreements reached
FMC, TSC, and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000,00
2.1.4 Letter of good faith signed by communities undertaking to negotiate in good faith with any eventual contract holder
FMC, TSC, and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000,00
Verification Guidance/ Procedure (LAS-LVD-0.2.1) | Verification Method | Verification Frequency
The law emphasizes the vital role of public participation in participatory governance, transparency and the decision-making process. The purpose of this procedure is to ensure that adequate adherence is given to this aspect in the determination and allocation of forestry resources within Liberia.
The FDA is mandated to decide on the use and allocation of forestry resources held in trust by the Government. In the decision of land use planning and validation of forestry resources, public participation fulfils a key role and there exists a duty on the FDA to engage with the relevant affected communities. With a view to ensuring adequate participation, requirements are placed on the FDA in terms of notifying, informing, conducting meetings, recording comments and considering the input of such communities. Such a participatory approach ensures that the views of relevant stakeholders are taken into consideration and that an informed decision is taken in terms of land use planning and the validation of forestry resources. Pursuant to an approved manual issued by the FDA following a participatory preparation process, the affected communities include those within 3,0 kilometres of the concession area.
The LVD shall verify that FDA plans its forest land use through statutorily required consultations with communities and other stakeholders. In the case of consultation with communities, the LVD shall confirm the fact and quality of the consultations by review of documentation, including the report of the socio-economic survey and the timing and arrangements relating to the conduct and discussions at the meetings. If necessary, other government agencies such as the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the relevant affected communities may be consulted.
Consultation with the FDA and, if necessary, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and affected communities
Document Review
Once during the contract period
References: NFRL (4.1-4.5); Regulation 102-07(21-22) Regulation 104-07(62) Section 87 of the PPC Act |
Indicator 2.2 Prior to allocation of the forest contract, FDA has obtained a Concession Certificate from the Ministry of Planning & Economic Affairs, approving the concession plan submitted by FDA and confirming that the proposed concession is consistent with national development objectives
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
2.2.1 Concession plan submitted by FDA to the Ministry of Planning & Economic Affairs (MPEA) in respect of the contract holder’s concession
FMC, TSC, and FUP having a value of US $ 10000,00 or more
2.2.2 Concession certificate (or a written approval) issued by the MPEA to FDA, authorizing FDA to commence concession/ contract allocation activity for the specified forest area
FMC, TSC, and FUP having a value of US $ 10000,00 or more
Verification Guidance/ Procedure (LAS-LVD-0.2.2) | Verification Method | Verification Frequency
The procedure aims to verify that the forestry objectives of Liberia are captured in the overall development plan of the country as endorsed by the MPEA through the issuance of a concession certificate.
The FDA must ensure that the forest to be allocated is suitable for commercial forestry and that a concession plan has been developed to ensure compliance with all requirements provided for by the NFRL and the PPC Act, respecting protected areas and rights of affected communities especially for use of non timber forest products.
The LVD must verify that the MPEA indeed issued a concession certificate to the FDA based on a review of the concession plan developed and submitted by FDA to ensure that the requirements for competitive bidding are met as provided for by the NFRL and the PPC Act. This is done through consultation with the FDA Legal and/or Commercial Department.
Consultation with PPCC and/or FDA Legal and Commercial Departments
Document review
Once during the contract period
References: Regulation 104-07 (5.2(a)(i)) PPC Act (46) |
Indicator 2.3 The Contract holder did comply with statutory prequalification requirements and was duly qualified by FDA to (i) operate in the forestry sector, and in the case of TSC and FMC, (ii) bid for the contract
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
2.3.1 Report of the prequalification committee regarding the prequalification process
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of US $ 10000,00 or more
2.3.2 Valid pre-qualification certificate issued the contract holder
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of US $ 10000,00 or more
2.3.3 Tax clearance showing no tax arrears at date of submission
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of US $ 10000,00 or more
2.3.4 Liquidity guarantee from reputable bank at date of submission
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of US $ 10000,00 or more
2.3.5 Business registration certificate predates pre-qualification certificate
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of US $ 10000,00 or more
Verification Guidance/ Procedure (LAS-LVD-0.2.3) | Verification Method | Verification Frequency
The aim of this procedure is to verify that a company applying for licensing has complied with all the relevant prequalification requirements and as such meets the criteria of the bidding process.
The FDA must ensure that all the pre-qualification requirements were met by a particular contract holder prior to the bidding process and/or obtaining the forest resource. The pre-qualification requirements inter alia include: (1) Articles of incorporation from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA), (2) Business registration certificate by the MOCI, (3) Tax clearance from the Ministry of Finance (MOF), and (4) Liquidity guarantee from a reputable bank.
The LVD must verify that the requirements were met in the time established by law. This means that the Prequalification Certificate must be predated by the contract holder or processor’s business registration certificate, tax clearance, and required bank guarantee.
Consultation with FDA, MOF, MOFA and the MOCI
Document Review
Once during the Contract period
References: NFRL (5.2(a)(i); Regulation 103-07 (41-46) |
Indicator 2.4 The forest contract was tendered in accordance with the competitive bidding process and rules established by the Public Procurement and Concessions Act and the Regulations issued by the FDA
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
2.4.1 Public tender notice
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000
2.4.2 Concession bid evaluation panel report
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000
2.4.3 Due diligence report by FDA
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000
2.4.4 Final report of bid evaluation panel to the Inter-Ministerial Concessions Committee (IMCC)
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000
2.4.5 IMCC recommendations to the President
FMC, TSC and FUP having a value of more than US $ 10000
Verification Guidance/ Procedure ( LAS-LVD-0.2.4) | Verification Method | Verification Frequency
The aim of this procedure is to verify that the forest license for commercial forest operations was granted based on a competitive bidding process as required by the law.
The law requires that once a bid is submitted, bids are evaluated by the concession bid evaluation panel, who then submit a bid evaluation report within 60 days to the concession entity (in this case the FDA). Thereafter FDA must conclude a due diligence report on all recommended bids. After that the concession bid evaluation panel will submit a final report to the IMCC. The IMCC will then review the report and submit its recommendations to the President for final decision.
The LVD must verify that the above requirements were met by firstly consulting and verifying the existence and validity of the required documents with the FDA Commercial Department and/or Legal Department. If further clarification is required, the LVD may consult with the Concession Bid Evaluation Committee and/or the IMCC.
Consultation with FDA, IMCC and PPCC
Document review
Once during the contract period
References: NFRL (3.3 &5.2(a)); PPC Act (115(1)&(2) and 116); and FDA Regulations 104, Section 31-36 |
Indicator 2.5: In case of a private use permit (PUP), the contract was awarded upon the written permission of the verified land owner
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
2.5.1 The valid deed of the private land owner
PUP
2.5.2 The written permission of the private land owner
PUP
Verification Guidance/ Procedure ( LAS-LVD-0.2.5) | Verification Method | Verification Frequency
The aim of this procedure is to ensure that the PUP is only granted where private land ownership is clearly established and upon the written approval of the land owner.
The LVD is required to verify the owner of a private land intended to be the subject of a PUP. This will entail checking the submitted deed against public records at the Center for National Records and Documentation (CNDRA).
The LVD must verify that the above requirements were met by first reviewing the titled deed to the land, and then confirming that the written permission is in fact from the land owner.
Consultation with CNDRA
Document review
Once during the contract period
References: NFRL Section 5.6 |
Indicator 2.6 In consultation with stakeholders and based on its socio-economic survey report, the FDA has prepared an integrated map showing the contract area and adjacent land areas such as other concessions, protected forest areas and private land
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
2.6.1 FDA map showing the subject concession area and indicates adjacent lands
FMC, TSC, FUP
2.6.2 FDA enforcement report (FDA compliance Audit Report)
FMC, TSC, FUP
Verification Guidance/ Procedure ( LAS-LVD-0.2.6) | Verification Method | Verification Frequency
The aim of this procedure is to verify that the concession area awarded to the contract holder does not encroach upon land owned by other contract holder(s) or protected forest area.
It is essential that every contract area is properly demarcated to avoid overlapping of concession areas or encroachment into protected forest areas.
The LVD should verify that these requirements were met checking the validity of the concession map with the FDA Research and Development Department and the Law Enforcement Department.
Consultation with FDA Research and Development and Law Enforcement Departments
Document review
Once during the contract period
References: COCS SOP (7, 8, 19, 20 & 21) Regulation 109-07 |
Indicator 2.7 The forest contract holder has submitted a bidder’s bond along with its bid for the forest contract to the FDA
Verifier | Contract or Permit Type
2.7.1 Bidder’s bond receipt issued the contract holder by FDA
FMC and TSC