35 III. ASSESSMENT › Market analysis › Production and first sale of electricity produced from conventional sources › (b) Other factors, Decision_act (EU) 2012/218

In forcesince 24 Apr 2012

In the last years, actually until March 2011, Germany was a net exporter of electricity. However, due to the decision to phase out production of electricity by several nuclear plants, Germany became a net importer. There is therefore currently a competitive pressure on the market deriving from the potential to import electricity from outside Germany. This ensures that investment in the electricity sector in Germany cannot be made without taking into account other producers in the surrounding countries. These factors should therefore be seen as not opposing the conclusion that contracting entities operating on the German production market from conventional sources are exposed to competition. Furthermore, an analysis of the situation in respect of customer switching [According to Table 2.1, page 6 and Table 2.2, page 7 of the Technical Annex to Commission Staff Working Paper ‘2009-2010 Report on Progress in Creating the Internal Gas and Electricity Market’ of June 2011, 2009 Germany had a customer switching for large industry of 10,7 % in volume and of 15,6 % by eligible meter point.] and the degree of liquidity on the wholesale market [According to the ‘Monitoring Benchmark Report 2011’ by Bundesnetzagentur für Elektrizität, Gas, Telekommunikation, Post und Eisenbahnen, page 28, the German wholesale market is extremely liquid. In 2010, the volume of wholesale trade amounts to an estimated 10600 TWh, which is more than 17 times the actual electricity demand in Germany.] show that these factors do not oppose the conclusion that contracting entities operating on the German production market from conventional sources are exposed to competition. Finally, it should also be noted that the German balancing market [Even though they represent a small part of the total amount of electricity produced and/or consumed in a Member State, the functioning of the balancing mechanisms should also be considered as an additional indicator. This is because if there is a large difference between the price at which transmission system operators provide balancing power and the price at which they buy back surplus production, this can be a problem for smaller market participants and undermine the development of competition.] and its main characteristics (market-based pricing and price difference between positive and negative balancing power) do not either oppose the conclusion that contracting entities operating on the German production market from conventional sources are exposed to competition.