94 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE › 5.2. Selective advantage › 5.2.3. Justification on the basis of the nature or the general scheme of the tax system of which it is part, Decision_act (EU) 2011/527

In forcesince 26 Jan 2011

Moreover, Germany claims that other Member States also provide tax relief for the restructuring of companies, such as the French aid scheme for the takeover of firms in difficulty. The Commission cannot accept Germany’s argument, which is based on a comparison. Firstly, in order to justify a measure, the Member States may refer only to principles inherent to their tax system, as the system of reference by which to assess whether an undertaking obtains an advantage with the meaning of the State aid rules. The fact that comparable tax measures might exist in the other Member States is of no consequence since any such measures could themselves be caught by the provisions in the Treaty. Secondly, the conditions imposed on measures under the French scheme differ from §8c(1a) KStG. The French scheme provides for a tax exemption for newly created companies which take over a firm in difficulty. After the scheme was declared incompatible within the common market by the Commission in 2004, [Case C 57/02 Tax exemption for the takeover of firms in difficulty (OJ L 108, 16.4.2004, p. 38).] France changed it to comply with the State aid rules. The benefits provided are now partly de minimis. The other part of the aid is compatible as regional aid or SME aid. [Case N 553/04 Tax exemption for the takeover of firms in difficulty (OJ C 242, 1.10.2005, p. 5).]

  • Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 14 July 2005. Compañía española para la fabricación de aceros inoxidables SA (Acerinox) v CommissioDecision

    14 Jul 2005 · 62002CJ0057