The Legality Assurance System (LAS) is a viable means of distinguishing forest products of lawful origin from those of unlawful origin, based on the definition of legal timber laid down in the text of this Voluntary Partnership Agreement (VPA). It makes it possible to ensure, at any time and anywhere within Cameroon, that only timber produced or acquired legally is in circulation, and may be granted a FLEGT licence when required. It functions on the basis of the following elements:
verification of the legality of the forestry entity [‘forestry entity’: natural or legal person, community, commune with a legal source for the production, acquisition or processing timber and derived products.];
national monitoring of forestry activities;
national control of forestry activities;
verification of the conformity of the supply chain;
issuing FLEGT licences;
an independent audit.
The LAS applies to all sources of production or acquisition of timber and timber products circulating within the national territory.
Timber imported [At present, only CEMAC timber (which originates from a country belonging to the Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa, other than Cameroon) is involved in import and transit, but cover under the system may be extended to any origin other than the CEMAC countries.] by forestry entities established in Cameroon will continue to be imported subject to the conditions laid down in the Cameroon legislation and regulations. Such timber does not trigger the issue of a FLEGT licence by the Cameroon issuing authorities unless it meets the origin rules (which are laid down in the economic partnership agreements) and meet at least one of the following requirements:
it holds a FLEGT licence from its country of origin,
it holds a private certificate recognised by the Cameroon Government as having originated from a sustainable management reference tool including at least the criteria required in the Cameroon legality matrices.
At all events, the legality of the timber imported by the forestry entities established in Cameroon is verified at the border before entering Cameroon and again when it enters the processing units, where it will be registered in the special ‘CEMAC plant entry’ books. Close cooperation with the other CEMAC countries will ensure avoidance of the import of illegal forestry products by Cameroon.
Timber in transit through Cameroon must be saved in the traceability system (in a database created in the second generation computer system administering forestry information – SIGIF II) and must follow a customs route defined for that purpose. The monitoring procedures for timber in transit will be defined in detail at a later date, during the implementation period, as will the information necessary in order to confirm the fact that the timber in question is in transit, based on the existing CEMAC procedures.
The definition of legality and the tools used to ensure the legality of the forestry entities are set out in Annex II. That Annex includes eight legality matrices produced in order to cover the different supply sources of the timber from the permanent forest domain (DFP), the non-permanent forest domain (DFNP) or the timber processing units (UTB):
Permanent forest domain
—Legality matrix 1logging agreement (CE),
—Legality matrix 2communal forest (FCle); State logging.
Non-permanent forest domain
—Legality matrix 3salvage licence (ARB),
—Legality matrix 4harvested timber removal licence (AEB),
—Legality matrix 5cut timber sale (VC) in the national domain,
—Legality matrix 6community forest (FC); State logging,
—Legality matrix 7special permit (PS); ebony logging in the national domain and the communal forests.
Timber processing units
—Legality matrix 8timber processing units (UTB).
With the exception of the UTB matrix, which has certain specific features, all the legality matrices are based on five (5) common criteria, covering the aspects of administration (criteria 1), logging and management (criteria 2), transportation (criteria 3), the social area (criteria 4) and the environment (criteria 5). Dependent on the matrices, these criteria are broken down into a variable number of indicators, which are in turn broken down into verifiers.
Verification of the conformity of the situation of every forestry entity with its verifiers is based on the technical documents stipulated in the regulatory texts issued by the various administrations and are, for the most part, available for consultation in the central database of the Ministry responsible for forests (SIGIF II). This verification work in relation to the legality of the forestry entity is undertaken within a formal structure of the Ministry responsible for forests in Yaoundé (see Annex III-B), using a flexible and rigorous procedure culminating in the issue of the certificate of legality to the logging/processing forestry entity, for every right awarded to it and/or every timber processing facility it owns. The procedures for issue of the ‘certificate of legality’ (identification of the documents of the administrative file, proper functioning of the system that reconciles the data from the various Ministries involved, procedure for renewal of the certificate of legality etc.) are defined in a special regulatory provision of the Ministry responsible for forests [This provision will be laid down during the operationalisation phase of the system.].
The ‘certificate of legality’ is issued for any given fiscal year, with a period of validity of:
at most 1 year for rights relating to the permanent forest domain (management agreement and communal forests),
at most 6 months for rights relating to the non-permanent forest domain,
at most 1 year for the processing units.
The certificate of legality may be suspended at any time following a dispute as described in Section V.
The central departments responsible for verifying legality may trigger site visits to check the authenticity of the verifiers set out in the corresponding legality matrix, which cannot always be fully understood on the basis of documentary analysis alone. These verifications also cover the elements supplied by the partner administrations (Ministry responsible for health, employment, social affairs, the environment and natural protection etc.), who issue documents required in the legality matrices.
The detailed procedure for verifying the legality of the forestry entity, and in particular the methods that will be used by the central departments responsible for verifying legality, will be drawn up during the preparatory phase.
In the specific case of forestry entities holding a private certificate of legality and/or sustainable forest management, which (i) is recognised and approved by the Minister responsible for forests, which defines the conditions of issue of approvals to certifiers and private auditors, (ii) has a credible and independent audit and (iii) uses a reference tool which must include all the requirements of the Cameroon legality matrices, these will be acknowledged as being in conformity with the legal situation in Cameroon. Such forestry entities will thus receive the ‘certificate of legality’ from the central departments responsible for verifying legality, on the basis of the valid certificate renewed annually, which will be requested during the monitoring audit.
Recognition by MINFOF of private certificates of legality and/or sustainable management will take place following an analysis of the reference tools used by the approved offices, in order to check that they have in fact included all the criteria, indicators and verifiers of the Cameroon legality matrices (administrative, logging and management, transport, social and environmental aspects). MINFOF will conduct a formal assessment of the private certification standards of the forest concessions in Cameroon, based on the legality matrix, during the preparatory phase. Following this assessment, a report will be drawn up, which will be published and publicly accessible. If the assessment is positive, the private certification system will be approved by the Minister responsible for forests under a regulatory provision. This approval will be published. It will hence allow the issue of a certificate of legality to companies certified under such a system, without any specific assessment having to be conducted, avoiding dual verification of legality in these certified forestry concessions. However, the forestry company receiving this approved certification must send the central departments responsible for verifying legality all the certification audit reports drawn up in relation to the private certification system, to enable it to monitor compliance with legality in this process, and thus enable the issue of the certificate of legality with respect to the enterprise and the right in question.
National monitoring of forestry activities is coordinated by the Ministry responsible for forests, via the specialist departments, and involves all the other administrations concerned in the national land management process. The monitoring tool is the second generation computer system administering forestry information (SIGIF II), whose central memory is located at the Ministry responsible for forests, with links (electronic links allowing information to be uploaded and real-time access) to the ‘MESURE’ tax system and the ‘SYDONIA’ customs system of the Ministry of Finance. It is therefore dependent not only on the proper functioning of those departments throughout the country, but also on positive collaboration with all the actors within the forestry industry.
SIGIF II is the IT tool with a central memory located at the Forests Division, on which all the data relating to the forestry industry originating from the forest and hunting control points, checkpoints, departmental delegations, regional delegations, forestry entities, tax and customs administrations etc., is held on file. It enables, at all times, the situation of every forestry entity to be ascertained and all necessary decisions in relation to the legality of their activities to be taken. It thus represents the main source of information capable of blocking the process leading to the issue of the FLEGT licence, when a forestry entity whose situation is irregular requests such a document; hence the use of the term ‘blocking system’.
MESURE (Meilleur suivi du rendement fiscal/improved monitoring of the tax yield) is a client/server application, which operates in the large enterprises division (DGE), in the forestry revenue security program (PSRF) and in the tax offices responsible for medium-sized enterprises (CIME) of the General Tax Directorate. Its main function is to monitor and manage taxes, fees, duties and charges. It offers a platform for entry, processing and analysis of declaration data in relation to forestry taxation. After the link with SIGIF II is set up, it will generate the following data:
general taxation data (patents, CNPS, taxes under existing law),
chart monitoring payment of the felling tax,
table monitoring payment of the plant entry tax,
chart relating to collections from public auctions and transactions,
chart monitoring collection and allocation of the RFA,
chart relating to payment of small rights,
approval expenses, expenses for the award of rights etc.
All this information is used in monitoring correspondence and enters the blocking system in the event of any irregularity.
SYDONIA: the customs IT system (SYDONIA) is a global application; it is used by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (Unctad), in several member countries of the World Customs Organization (WCO). It is a server/user application, which is currently used by the Cameroon customs administration. Under the link with SIGIF II, it communicates the following information in real-time:
statistical data relating to quantities exported:
national log exports,
exports of logs in transit (CEMAC),
national exports of sawn timber,
exports of sawn timber in transit (CEMAC),
exports of parquet,
exports of plywood,
exports of veneers,
exports of special products,
exports of finished timber products,
statistical data on the global taxable values of the quantities exported,
statistical data on the budgetary revenue generated by the timber exports,
data relating to the forestry entities suspended from customs activity and the reasons for their suspension,
data relating to the discharge of payments and the volumes granted either by the General Tax Directorate (DGI) or MINFOF,
data relating to the volumes of logs exported by certain forestry entities holding special licences (export of logs of category 2 promotion species),
data relating to the number of FLEGT licences accompanying the shipments actually loaded,
data on the quantities of CEMAC timber in transit or imported.
As in the case of MESURE, all the SYDONIA information is used in monitoring correspondence and enters the blocking system in the event of any irregularity.
National control of forestry activities is undertaken on a day-to-day basis along the entire supply chain. All the information obtained is saved in the traceability system and enters the central database SIGIF II. This is undertaken by all the specialist departments of the Ministry responsible for forests, assisted by the forces responsible for keeping order and the Justice Ministry. It takes place in conformity with the ‘National Strategy for Forestry and Fauna Control’, which applies to the individual stages of the supply chain and is based, inter alia, on the traceability system described in this Annex. Amended control procedures will be drawn up during the preparatory phase, in order to take account of the requirements of the Legality Assurance System.
The forestry control activities may give rise to disputes, which are managed using the software tool ‘Monitoring offences and IT management of forestry disputes’ (SIGICOF), a module linked to SIGIF II. The conclusions of the forestry complaint will be used in the blocking system against any forestry entity committing an offence, as soon as it has been declared guilty by the competent courts. These conclusions are therefore set out in the record of offences within the SIGIF II database and continue to block for the entity in question (i.e. prevent the issue of the certificate of legality), while not having yet produced all the legal effects laid down in the applicable regulations.
This is the traceability system for timber and derived products in Cameroon.
The traceability system will be capable of monitoring the trace of the timber and timber products from the forest to the point of export, including all intermediate points. This traceability system thus allows entry of the results of the logging inventory, all the volumes felled, transported, entering the plant and processed, and all the CEMAC products imported or in transit.
Verification of conformity of the supply chain covers the entire national territory, all the production or acquisition methods (forestry concession, cut timber sale, community forests, communal forests, salvage licences and public auctions) and all forestry products exported, imported, in transit and exchanged within the country.
The system is designed on the basis of the following principles:
it is a central database (SIGIF II), which is accessible online by all the actors involved in the timber sector,
it is linked to the databases of other administrations or departments, for the purposes of linking and consolidating information [SIGIF II, SIGICOF, SYDONIA, MESURE] in real-time,
it functions in client/server mode, with regulated access to the server (group, rights etc.). Data is uploaded in real-time by all those using the system (loggers, industrial operators, exporters, importers, tax administration, customs administration and forest administration),
it permits transparency of the sector, by providing online access to reliable and relevant information to the benefit of the actors dealing with forestry problems,
it sets up the logging inventory: every tree listed under the existing legislation is given a reference number (barcode),
it is electronic (fast and reliable) and is at the same time documentary (waybills, worksite books etc.),
it is declarative and increases accountability (in both tax and forestry terms). The forestry entity is made accountable through the fact that it is itself responsible for blockages and delays: if it fails to send its felling (and other) declarations, it penalises itself as regards downstream operations (export),
it is compatible with the systems established in neighbouring countries and with those set up by the forestry entities,
it has a blocking effect in relation to the member groups, to the rights granted to each group and to the encoding of the centrally secured databases. The traceability system must include validation of data entered at every stage. (e.g.: issue of the permit by the central MINFOF requires entry of the logging inventory data),
it is a system designed to simplify the control procedures, in particular through reduction of the number of control points (identification of mandatory points of passage), through the electronic link which facilitates information exchange etc.
As indicated above, the actors may encode, transmit or consult the data in SIGIF II at various levels along the traceability chain. The flow of data transmission/consultation between the actors is set out in the flowchart below:
Definition of the roles of the individual actors:
—MINFOF central office
management of the system and regulation of procedures,
encoding of basic information,
supervision of control,
links with other administrations,
validation of data at central level,
independent audit.
—The forestry entities
uploading data on their activities (inventories, felling, transportation, processing, import and export) or transmission to the departments responsible for uploading onto the database,
uploading information on felling tax (TA), plant entry tax (TEU), annual forestry fee (RFA) and existing taxes, to monitor correspondence, or transmission to the departments responsible for uploading onto the database.
—The joint border teams
uploading data on timber from neighbouring countries,
control and verification of documents,
provision of specific barcodes for timber in transit, as necessary.
—The regional and departmental delegations responsible for forests
uploading data from specification bulletins on timber for export (BSE),
uploading data on control and documentary verification undertaken at the forestry and hunting control post (PCFC),
uploading data relating to the auction sale of confiscated products (VEB).
—Checkpoints
uploading physical control data,
reading barcodes.
—The entity responsible for issuing FLEGT licences
uploading data referred to on the FLEGT licences issued,
physical documentary control,
the issue of FLEGT licences.
—Tax administration
uploading information on felling tax (TA), plant entry tax (TEU), annual forestry fee (RFA) and existing taxes, to monitor correspondence.
—Customs
uploading information in relation to quantities loaded, imported, in transit,
physical and documentary verification,
uploading customs revenue information.
—Other countries
consultation via the links between traceability systems.
—Other actors
reading, observation, exposure and suggestions.
The organisational procedures of the institutional actors called upon to play an essential part in implementing the LAS are set out in Annex III-B.
The table below sets out the broad outlines of the traceability system to be set up. The procedures specific to each stage in the supply chain will be devised during the preparatory phase, with external technical assistance support over a limited period and after field testing. These specific procedures defining the frequency of controls/verifications, sampling methods, field control procedures, record of offences, processing of CEMAC timber etc., will be set out in a procedure manual drawn up and distributed to all the actors involved. Specific equipment and resources will be made available to the departments responsible for monitoring traceability.
[The timber confiscated and sold at auction at any stage will enter the traceability chain at that point and will follow all the subsequent stages of the chain]
Milestones | Operations | Responsibility for the operation | Data to be encoded | Responsibility for the encoding | Verification (physical and documentary control) | Data reconciliation
Forests
Logging inventories |
Operators via research departments approved for undertaking inventories
MINFOF (prior inventories in the salvage licences)
→ Marking of every inventorised tree with a bar-coded label
barcode
logger
fiscal year
species code
diameter at breast height (DHP) (1,3 m)
GPS coordinates
right No/UFA (Forest Management Unit)/block/annual allowable cuts (AAC)
Data entry by the operators and recording in SIGIF II
Inventory card recorded in the Central Unit of Forest Mapping (UCECAF)
Field control by MINFOF of the quality/viability of the inventory (central and devolved departments) based on sampling (verification rules) | Test for coherence with the management inventories (in particular in relation to inventorised species)
Felling |
Operators
→ Marking of the stump and the felled log with new bar-coded labels (same barcode as the standing tree)
barcode
DF10 (worksite book) No
logger
subcontractor
AAC No
area
species code
length
Largest diameter end
Smallest diameter end
Date
Entry of data by the operators on the DF10 worksite books and recording in SIGIF II | Field control by MINFOF (devolved departments, National Control Team (BNC) and the Independent Observer (OI)) |
Test for automatic coherence in the SIGIF II between the volume/number of standing trees felled and authorised.
Interface with MESURE database of the Ministry of Finance (MINFI) (felling tax)
Transportation of logs:
forest – export
forest – plant
forest intermediate depot
intermediate depot – export
intermediate depot – plant
Preparation and loading at the timber depot in the forest (to the plant, export or intermediate depot) |
Operators
→ Marking with new bar-coded labels on the prepared billets (linked to the barcode on the original log)
barcode
log waybill No
DF10 No (+ line and position)
AAC No
departure No (timber depot)
destination
carrier
species code
length
largest diameter end
smallest diameter end
date
agent (+ logging hammer No)
vehicle registration
Entry by the operators on the log waybill and recording in SIGIF II |
Field control by MINFOF (devolved departments, BNC and the OI) with systematic verification
and at checkpoints, of the validity/viability of the documents, recording of barcodes and physical verification of volumes in the log waybill declarations