The legality of timbers placed on the market is based on compliance with national laws and regulations and duly ratified international legal instruments, the application of which is necessary in order to guarantee the viability of forest management by the producing and/or exporting enterprise, its suppliers and subcontractors, in the name of the owners of the forest (the State, the local government district, a private owner or a community).
The definition of legality drawn up by consensus by all the stakeholders in this spirit may be summarised thus:
‘Any timber which has been verified/controlled as originating or coming from one or more production or acquisition processes that meet all of the statutory and regulatory provisions in force in Cameroon applicable to the forest sector shall be deemed to be legal timber.’
The definition of the legality of the commercial timbers is based on the knowledge and application of the laws and regulations in force in Cameroon, and on compliance with the international legal instruments duly ratified by Cameroon in the forest, commercial, environmental, social and human rights fields. The national laws and regulations under consideration include in particular:
the Constitution of the Republic of Cameroon,
Law No 81-13 governing forests, wildlife and fishing of 27 November 1981, not fully repealed, and its implementing texts (including implementing Decree No 83-169 of 12 April 1983, not repealed),
the new forest law No 94-01 governing forests, wildlife and fishing of 20 January 1994, and its implementing texts (including PM Decree No 94-436 of 23 August 1994 (of which not all the provisions have been repealed), PM Decree No 95-531 of 1995 and other decisions and circulars in force),
the framework law relating to environmental management, No 96/12 of 5 August 1996, and its implementing texts,
Order No 222 MINEF [Ministry of the Environment and Forests.] of 25 May 2001 laying down the procedures for implementing the DFP [Permanent forest domain.] forest management plans,
Law No 2002/003 of 19 April 2002 setting out the General Tax Code,
the legislation governing investment (Law No 2002/004 of 19 April 2002 relating to the investment charter, amended by Law No 2004/020 of 22 July 2004),
Decree No 99/781/PM of 13 October 1999 laying down the application procedures for Article 71(1) of Forest Law No 94/01 of 20 January 1994 governing forests, wildlife and fishing,
Decree No 2005/577 of 23 February 2005 on EIEs and Order No 0069 MINEP [Ministry of the Environment and Nature Protection.] of 8 March 2005 on the categories subject to EIEs [Environmental impact study.],
the various annual finance laws,
the Employment Code, Law No 92-007 of 14 August 1992,
the legislation governing social security [See Caisse nationale de prévoyance sociale, Recueil des textes de base (1979).],
the phytosanitary regulations (MINADER [Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development.]),
the national collective bargaining agreement (April 2002) of the companies involved in logging and in the processing of forest products and associated activities (exercise of the right to form a union, staff representative, employment contract, working conditions and salaries, health and safety, etc.).
The international legal instruments referred to above include, inter alia:
the Treaty on the Conservation and Sustainable Management of Forest Ecosystems of Central Africa and establishing the Central Africa Forests Commission – COMIFAC (February 2005),
the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), signed on 3 March 1973 and amended on 22 June 1979,
the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), signed in June 1992.
The application of the provisions of these international legal instruments shall follow their transposition into the national legislative texts.
Any amendment to these texts and any new legislation in this field will give rise to a subsequent amendment to this Annex.
The following elements were also taken into consideration when drafting this definition of legality:
the various initiatives developed on the subject of legality (TFT-TTAP [Private-sector association by the name of the Tropical Forest Trust, which manages a support project to the private sector involving checking legality (the Timber Trade Action Programme).], REM [Resource Extraction Monitoring.], TRAFFIC [WWF traceability and legal compliance project.], CoC [Chain of Custody, traceability system.], FSC [Forest Stewardship Council.] etc.),
the PROFOREST proposal [Project financed by the Union.] of 6 September 2005 relating to traceability,
the ‘FLEGT Briefing Notes’ [Briefing note on the Union action plan on Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade.] published by the European Union,
the reference tool FORCOMS (Forest Concession Monitoring System) relating to conformity to regulations, first version 2005, followed by consolidated version of February 2007 for Cameroon),
the tools OLB-BVQI [Legal Origin of Wood/Bureau Véritas.] and TLTS-SGS [Timber Legality and Traceability Verification/Société générale de surveillance.] of February 2006 relating to legality,
the report ‘Definition of legal timber according to the texts and regulations in force in Cameroon’ (GTZ/PGDRN [Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (German Technical Cooperation Society)/Sustainable Natural Resources Management Programme.] – MINFOF [Ministry of Ministry of Forestry and Wildlife.]) of 15 February 2006,
the report ‘Legality of VPA Timber in Cameroon (comparative approach of different systems)’, GTZ document of May 2006,
the COMIFAC [Central African Forest Commission.] report (WRI [World Resource Institute.] -UICN [International Union for Conservation of Nature.] -IFIA [International Forest Industry Association.]) on the FORCOMS project phase II of February 2007,
the draft legal text by COMIFAC on forest control in Central Africa of October 2007,
the PCI [Principles, criteria, indicators.] OAB/OIBT [African Timber Organisation/International Tropical Timber Organisation.] & audit manual/OIBI series No 14 – 2003.
Based on the definition of legality, Cameroon has produced a set of legality matrices intended to be used to check conformity of the operation (against the legal provisions) of the forestry entities [‘forestry entity’: any natural or legal person, community, municipality with a legal source for the production, acquisition or processing of timber or derived products.] active in Cameroon, as well as that of the products they produce. These matrices are the result of participatory and ongoing work incorporating the concerns of the various stakeholders.
The broad range of legality matrices stems from the fact that Cameroon forest legislation stipulates many timber supply methods, in relation to which the legality concerns differ. Each of the matrices has thus been designed to clearly highlight the specific legal requirements associated with each of the supply methods stipulated by the Cameroon legislation. Bearing in mind these specific features, eight legality matrices have already been produced for different timber supply sources: the permanent forest domain (DFP) is made up of land definitively allocated to forest, the non-permanent forest domain (DFNP) is made up of forest land which may be allocated to uses other than forest domain (agro-forest domain), and finally, the timber processing units (UTB).
In the permanent forest domain (DFP)
—legality matrix 1 (LM1)logging agreement (CE),
—legality matrix 2 (LM2)communal forest (FCle); State logging.
In the non-permanent forest domain (DFNP)
—legality matrix 3 (LM3)salvage licence (ARB),
—legality matrix 4 (LM4)harvested timber removal licence (AEB),
—legality matrix 5 (LM5)cut timber sale (VC) in the national domain,
—legality matrix 6 (LM6)community forest (FC); State logging,
—legality matrix 7 (LM7)special permit (PS); ebony logging in the national domain and the communal forests.
In the timber processing units (UTB)
—legality matrix 8 (LM8)timber processing units (UTB).
The table below summarises the various timber supply sources and the associated legality matrices.
Title
Supply source
CE | VC | ARB | AEB | State | PS | PBO | APC
F. Private estate forest (FD) | LM1 | | | LM4 | | | |
F. Communal forest (Cle) | | | | LM4 | LM2 | LM7 | |
F. National domain forest (FDN) | | LM5 | LM3 | LM4 | | LM7 | |
F. Community forest (FC) | | | | LM4 | LM6 | | |
F. Private forest (FP) | | | | | | | |
Timber processing unit (UTB) | LM8
In order to cover all the different means of access to the timber resource that are available under existing legislation and are listed below, other legality matrices will be produced during the system operationalisation phase, whenever they are found to be relevant.
These are:
Legality matrix for private forests (FP),
Legality matrix for lumber permits (PBO),
Legality matrix for personal timber licences (APC),
Legality matrices of communal forests (FCle) and community forests (FC), when logging other than State logging takes place (VC, PBO, APC).
The legality matrices are made up of criteria, indicators and verifiers, and are involved in the global Legality Assurance System (LAS), the functioning of which is described in detail in Annex III-A.
The criteria and indicators have been analysed and subsequently tested in the field for all the matrices, and only the criteria and indicators of relevance in each specific matrix have been retained.
With the exception of the matrix relating to timber processing units, the legality matrices have been drawn up on the basis of five (5) common criteria, which deal respectively with the regularity:
of the administrative and legal aspects (criteria 1),
of the logging and forest management (criteria 2),
of the transport (criteria 3),
of the social aspects (criteria 4),
of the environmental aspects (criteria 5).
Dependent on the matrices, these criteria are broken down into a variable number of indicators, which reflect the different legal obligations associated with these different timber supply sources.
The conformity of the indicators is assessed on the basis of the verifiers. For an indicator to ‘conform’, all the associated verifiers must first be deemed to conform.
The conformity of the verifier is based on the availability of the technical documents issued by the various administrations, which are stipulated in the regulatory texts and are, for the most part, available for consultation in the central database of the Ministry responsible for forests (second generation computer system administering forestry information – SIGIF II).
The issue of a ‘certificate of legality’, which represents one of the requirements for the issue of a FLEGT licence (see Annex III-A), is only possible provided all the indicators conform.
Article 41 of Law 94/01 of 20 January 1994
Articles 35(1), 36, 114 and 140(1), (2), (3), (4) and (5), of Decree 95-531
Law 98/015 of 14 July 1998 relating to establishments classified as dangerous, unhealthy or obnoxious
Decree 99/818/PM of 9 November 1999 laying down the provisions for setting up and operating [the establishments in question]
Order No 013/MINEE/DMG/SL (Ministry of Energy and Water/Mines and Geology Division/SL of 19 April 1977 repealing and replacing Order No 154 of 28 March 1957 coding dangerous, unhealthy or obnoxious establishments
1.1.1 Certificate of domicile (natural person)
1.1.2 Commercial register maintained at the competent court office
1.1.3 Forestry approval granted by the competent authority
1.1.4 Extract from the registration of the logging hammer stamps with the office of the competent Court of Appeal
1.1.5 Authority to set up and operate a first class establishment from the Ministry responsible for the industry
1.1.6 Certificate of registration as a timber processor from the Ministry responsible for forests
Articles 46, 47(1), (2) and (3) and 50(1) of Law 94/01
Articles 61, 75(1), 76(4), and 77 of Decree 95/531
Articles 68, 69 and 70 of Decree 95/53
1.2.1 Notice of public invitation to tender
1.2.2 Receipt for registration of a complete file relating to the award of the forestry concession
1.2.3 Notification of the results of the interministerial committee selecting the forestry entity as the best bidder, by the Minister responsible for forests
1.2.4 Proof of deposit of the surety with the Public Revenue Department within the prescribed deadlines
1.2.5 Provisional logging agreement signed by the Minister responsible for forests
1.2.6 Receipts/requests for transfer addressed to the Ministry responsible for forests by the concession holder and the applicant
1.2.7 Notification of transfer of the concession by the competent authority
1.2.8 Receipts for payment of the transfer tax stipulated by law
1.2.9 Certificate of conformity with the clauses of the provisional logging agreement
1.2.10 Order approving the management plan issued by the Minister responsible for forests
1.2.11 Five-year management plan and operation plan for the current year
1.2.12 Terms and conditions signed by the competent authority and the forestry entity
1.2.13 Deed of classification
1.2.14 Authority to set up and operate a first class establishment from the Ministry responsible for the industry, or receipt of declaration (2nd class)
1.2.15 Certificate of registration as a timber processor from the Ministry responsible for forests
Articles 41 and 42 of Law 94/01
Articles 35(1), 36, 114 and 140(1), (2), (3), (4) and (5) of Decree 95-531
1.3.1 Subcontracting/partnership agreement
1.3.2 Letter of approval of the subcontracting agreement, issued by the Ministry responsible for forests
1.3.3 Receipt for registration of the agreement approved by the local authorities of the Ministry responsible for forests
1.3.4 Commercial register maintained at the competent court office
1.3.5 Forestry approval granted by the competent authority (logging)
1.3.6 Authority to set up and operate a first class establishment from the Ministry responsible for the industry (processing)
1.3.7 Certificate of registration as a timber processor from the Ministry responsible for forests (processing)
1.3.8 Extract from the registration of the logging hammer with the office of the competent court
Articles 146, 150 and 152 of Law 94/01
Chapter 3 of Law 94/01
Articles 130, 131, 132, 135(2), 136 and 137 of Decree 95-531
1.4.1 Records/files of offences published by the competent administrations
1.4.2 Register of disputes of the competent local departments
1.4.3 Suspension decision of the Minister responsible for forests, substantiated and challenged, if applicable
Articles 66 and 69 of Law 94/01
Article 122 of Decree 95-531
Revised General Tax Code (Part 1, Chapter 1; Part 2, Chapter 1; Part 5, Chapter 3)
Finance Law 2002/003 and subsequent revisions
1.5.1 Tax patent
1.5.2 Certificate of solvency/tax certificate of the competent tax office
Articles 23, 40(3), 63 and 64 of Law 94/01
Article 35 of Decree 95-531
2.1.1 Approval of the enterprise or its various subcontractors having been involved in certain management activities (inventories, forestry)
2.1.2 Service contracts with (an) approved structure(s) or a public body
Articles 44 and 46 of Law 94/01
The standard model of the provisional and definitive agreement and the associated terms and conditions under sheets 2 and 3 (PROC)
Article 17 of Law 96/12 of 5 August 1996 setting out a framework law on environmental management
Article 20 of Decree 0577 of 23 February 2005
2.2.1 Letter of approval of the terms of reference for the audit/environmental impact study
2.2.2 Environmental conformity certificate
2.2.3 Annual harvesting site certificate (CAAC) or annual operating permit (PAO)
2.2.4 Notification of the start of activities
Articles 51(1) and 73(1), (2) of Decree 95-531
Articles 4(1), (2), (3), (4) and (6), 12(1) and (2) and 13(1) and (2) of Order No 222
Sheets 6, 14 and 17 PROC
Logging inventory rules
Rules on activities in forest areas (NIMF)
2.3.1 Count certificate or certificate confirming respect of the logging rules
Articles 46(3), 72(1) and 125(2) and (3) of Decree 95-531
Article 6 of Order No 222
Rules on activities in forest areas (NIMF)
Sheet 6 PROC
2.4.1 Worksite books (DF10) or SIGIF declaration
2.4.2 Count certificate
Articles 66, 67 and 69 of Law 94
Article 122 of Decree 95-531
Revised General Tax Code (Part 1, Chapter 1; Part 2, Chapter 1; Part 5, Chapter 3)
Finance Law 2002/003 and subsequent revisions
2.5.1 Certificate of registration of the bank guarantee if required under the articles of association of the entity
2.5.2 Payment receipts (annual forestry charge [RFA], felling tax [TA], plant entry tax [TEU]), local development taxes or other forestry taxes if stipulated in the terms and conditions) for the current year and the year preceding the year of verification
Articles 115(1), (2) and (3), 127(1) and 128 of Decree 95-531
3.1.1 Secure waybills, signed by the competent authority
3.1.2 Certificate of legality of the supplier(s)
Articles 127(1) and 128 of Decree 95-531
3.2.1 Import licences issued by the competent authorities responsible for forests and finance
3.2.2 International waybills stamped for the entire route
3.2.3 Certificates of origin and phytosanitary certificates from the exporting country
3.2.4 FLEGT licences from the country of origin, or any other private certificate of legality/sustainable management recognised by Cameroon (reference tool of the private certificate system incorporating the principal elements of the Cameroon legality matrices)
Articles 127(2) and (3) and 128 of Decree 95-531
3.3.1 Waybill secured and signed by the competent authority of the Ministry responsible for forests, for the transportation of logs and cut timber by road
3.3.2 Special declaration on note stamped by the competent manager in the event of transportation by rail
3.3.3 Loading certificate of the competent customs department (transport in containers) together with the loading report of the forestry department and the place of loading
Articles 61(2) and 62(2) of Law No 92/007 of 14 August 1992 setting out the Employment Code
Decree No 2008/2115 of 24 January 2008 revaluing the minimum guaranteed interprofessional salary (SMIG)
Ordinance No 73-17 of 22 May 1973 organising social security
Decree 74-26 of 11 January 1974 laying down the application arrangements of certain provisions of Ordinance No 73-17 of 22 May 1973 organising the National Social Security Fund
Decree No 74-723 of 12 August 1974 laying down the rates of contributions owed to the CNPS (National Social Security Fund) for the family allowances and the old age pension, invalidity pension and death benefit insurance
Law No 69-LF-18 of 10 November 1969 establishing a scheme for old age pension, invalidity and death benefit insurance, amended by Law No 84/007 of 4 July 1984
Order No 039/MTPS/IMT of the Ministry of Labour and Social Security (MTPS) laying down the general provisions relating to health and safety at the workplace
Order No 019/MTPS/SG/CJ of the Ministry of Labour and Social Security of 26 May 1993 laying down the election arrangements and conditions for exercise of the duties of staff representatives
The national collective bargaining agreement (April 2002) of the companies involved in logging and in the processing of forest products and associated activities
Order No 11/DEC/DT (Employment Division) of 25 May 1978 laying down the arrangements for the summoning and appearance of the Parties before the Employment Inspector for the settlement of employment disputes
Practical directives from the International Labour Organization (ILO)
Law 64/LF/23 of 13 November 1964 protecting public health
Law 98/015 of 14 July 1998 relating to establishments classified as dangerous, unhealthy or obnoxious
Decree 99/818/PM of 9 November 1999 laying down the provisions for setting up and operating [the establishments in question]
Currently valid matrix of the salaries of the enterprises involved in logging and in the processing of forest products and associated activities
4.1.1 Certificate of registration issued by the CNPS
4.1.2 Employer registers in 3 parts, listed and signed by the competent court or by the employment inspector of the administrative district
4.1.3 Internal rules stamped by the employment inspector of the administrative district
4.1.4 Reports on the election of staff representatives
4.1.5 Agreement on visits and care with a general practitioner
4.1.6 Instrument establishing a workplace health and safety committee, signed by the manager of the enterprise
4.1.7 Inspection reports of the Ministry of Health
4.1.8 Declaration of establishment sent to the employment inspector of the administrative district
Articles 36 and 61(1) and (3) of Law 94/01
Article 85 of Decree No 95/531
Articles 5 and 6 of Order No 222 laying down the procedures for the preparation and approval of PAs
Article 14 of the model terms and conditions of the final agreement
Decision 135/B/MINEF/CAB of 26 November 1999 laying down the forest classification procedures of the permanent forest domain
Decision No 0108/D/MINEF/CAB of 9 February 1998 applying the Rules on activities in forest areas
Chapter II of the Rules on activities in forest areas
4.2.1 Terms and conditions
4.2.2 Reports on the realisation of the social projects laid down in the terms and conditions
4.2.3 Minutes of the information meeting on logging under the forestry right, signed by the all the stakeholders
4.2.4 Land allocation map
4.2.5 Report on the socioeconomic studies
4.2.6 Minutes of the meeting reinstating the socioeconomic study
4.2.7 Record/file of offences/report
Articles 95 and 101(1) of Law 94/01
Article 11(1) and (3) of Order No 222
Decision No 0108/D/MINEF/CAB of 9 February 1998 applying the Rules on activities in forest areas
Terms and conditions of the final agreement
Chapter VI of the Rules on activities in forest areas (Articles 28, 29 and 30)
5.1.1 Internal rules
5.1.2 Memoranda giving details of the ban on poaching and transportation of bush meat
5.1.3 Memoranda publishing any penalties
5.1.4 Food supply plan
5.1.5 Record of offences
Article 18(1), (2) and (3) of Law 94/01
Articles 3 and 4 of Order 0069/MINEP of 8 March 2005
Decree 0577 of 23 February 2005
Article 11(1) and (2) of Order No 222 of 25 May 2001
Article 16 of the terms and conditions of the CDE (Enterprise Development Centre) defining the special observations on logging around the periphery of the protected areas (buffer strip) (UFA [Forest Management Unit])
Decision No 0108/D/MINEF/CAB of 9 February 1998 applying the Rules on activities in forest areas
Articles 17, 79 and 82 of Law 96/12 of 5 August 1996 setting out a framework law on environmental management
Guide on environmental measures in relation to logging
5.2.1 Environmental inspection report
5.2.2 Certificate confirming respect of the environmental clauses
5.2.3 Record of environmental offences
Articles 30 and 35 of Law 94/01
Article 17 of Decree 95-531