V. CONCLUSIONS, Decision_act (EU) 2011/6

In forcesince 20 Jul 2010
(132)

The Commission concludes that:

Portugal has illegally funded campaigns for the generic promotion of wine financed by means of a charge on domestic products and on products imported from other Member States, contrary to Article 108(3) of the TFEU,

The only training measure funded by revenue from the parafiscal charge does not constitute an aid,

Aid in favour of the promotion and generic advertising of wine and wine products conducted by Viniportugal on Portugal’s territory can be declared compatible with the common market,

Aid for the promotion and advertising of wine and wine products of Portuguese origin on the territory of other Member States and third countries which are funded by means of a charge on the production of wine and wine products affecting also products from other Member States have complied with the applicable Community provisions so far as those beneficiaries are concerned. The Commission also notes the existence of a breach of Article 110 of the TFEU as regards funding of the aid. For this reason, the Commission cannot declare the arrangements in question as compatible since they created discrimination between imported and domestic products.