6. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 6.3. Assessment of SME status of Sovello › 6.3.3. Company documents and factual situation, Decision_act (EU) 2010/358

In forcesince 27 Jan 2010
(88)

Several elements suggest that from the start the intention of Evergreen and Q-Cells was to give equal power to both partners as soon as the SME bonus was secured:

The MJVA1 lays down in its Article 3(6) that, ‘if it is possible under the applicable grant regulations, that Q-Cells increases its ownership interest in Sovello to 50 %, without such increase of Q-Cells’ ownership interest in Sovello possibly resulting in an application for Government Investment Grants being turned down, (…), then Q-Cells shall be offered to increase its ownership interest in Sovello to a level equal to the percentage’ then held by Evergreen. In this context, a preferential price shall apply.

The MJVA1 contains in its Article 3(6) even an emergency plan, foreseeing to find other ways than shareholding participation to increase Q-Cells ownership, if necessary:

‘If at the time of an Additional Financing request the Grant Impunity Notice cannot be obtained, the Parties shall enter into discussions as to whether Q can participate in the Additional Financing to the extent necessary to enable it to increase its ownership in VentureCo to 50 %, as provided herein, in a manner other than by share subscription.’ [‘VentureCo’ stands for EverQ; ‘Q’ stands for Q-Cells. The Grant Impunity Notice is the written confirmation of the German authorities that the ownership increase is possible under the applicable grant regulations without resulting in a lowering of the grant or in a reimbursement obligation.](Underlining added)