The German GmbH Statute creates certain statutory minority rights in several paragraphs, in particular in §§ 50, 61, 66, and 53. The minority rights contained in §§ 50, 61, and 66 refer to rights of shareholders exceeding 10 % of votes, and are therefore irrelevant for the present assessment, since they are acquired by Q-Cells. Only § 53 contains a minority right which is not obtained by statute by Q-Cells by virtue of its share of 24,9 %. According to § 53, a minority of more than 25 % of the voting rights is entitled to block a modification of the Articles of Association of the limited company. By sole application of the law, Evergreen, as majority shareholder with voting rights exceeding 75 % could thus indeed take all important business decisions, including on changes to the Articles of Association. If the decisional rights included in the provisions of the Articles of Association and the MJVA did not contain additional decisional rights in favour of Q-Cells, the argument brought forward by Germany that Evergreen needed a share exceeding 75 % was credible, and the 24,9 % share of Q-Cells could be justified as the consequence of strict application of statutory rights, and could therefore be considered not to reflect an artificial corporate architecture aimed at circumventing the SME definition.
105 6. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 6.3. Assessment of SME status of Sovello › 6.3.3. Company documents and factual situation, Decision_act (EU) 2010/358
In forcesince 27 Jan 2010