138 VI. AID ASSESSMENT › 3. Compatibility of aid with the common market › Compatibility of the aid to Huta Częstochowa, Decision_act (EU) 2006/937

In forcesince 5 Jul 2005

Second, the aid measures are compatible with the R&D framework. Clearly, the aid was awarded for the purposes of R&D. In addition, the aid remains below the ceiling for compatible aid as indicated in the R&D framework assuming an additional bonus of 10 % as the recipient was situated in an Article 87(3) (a) region [See Commission letter to Poland dated 13.08.2004, which did not raise any objections to the notified measures, including the Polish regional aid map (C(2004)3230/5).]. It is either aid for industrial research and remains below the ceiling of 60 % (point 0 of subparagraph 1, 2 and 4) or aid which is used for either industrial research or pre-competitive development and which remains below the ceiling for pre-competitive development of 35 % (point 0 of subparagraph 3, 4 and 5). The aid also had an incentive effect as the Polish authorities have convincingly demonstrated that HCz would not have commissioned the R&D without it.