As for the price of the guarantee, the Commission has no evidence that the premium paid does not correspond to the market price. That is obvious if the Polish authorities' argument is accepted that, because of the contractual arrangements, the guaranteed sum did not exceed PLN 6 million and the premium was therefore 2 %. However, even in the case of a premium of 0,8 %, examples of similar guarantees with premiums of 1 % indicate that the premium was a market rate, in particular if one bears in mind that TFS had comprehensive information about HSCz and had thus been able to set up a monitoring system which allowed the guaranteed sum to be limited. In addition, the Commission recalls that in other steel cases it took the view that the correct premium was even lower than in the present case [See Commission Decision Anon of 26 July 2004, C(2004)1813 fin, point 47, not yet published, in which the Commission accepts a premium of 0,6 %.].
127 VI. AID ASSESSMENT › 2. Existence of aid › a) Aid for the restructuring of Huta Częstochowa and application of the private creditor test › Existence of aid as regards Huta Stali Częstochowa's activities, Decision_act (EU) 2006/937
In forcesince 5 Jul 2005
Judgment of the Court (Second Chamber) of 14 September 2004. Kingdom of Spain v Commission of the European Communities.Decision
14 Sep 2004 · 62002CJ0276