Firstly, as argued above, the existence of exemptions to which certain firms can have recourse cannot be justified by the fact that other exemptions exist. In this context it matters little that there are more companies with an exemption than firms obliged to pay or deduct withholding tax. Given that there are differences in the application of withholding tax and that these exemptions confer on the beneficiaries an advantage not enjoyed by non-beneficiaries, these differences are potentially caught by Article 87 of the EC Treaty, and it is necessary to determine whether the advantage conferred does in fact constitute aid; if it does, its compatibility with the common market should be assessed.
Recital 81, Decision_act (EU) 2003/757
In forcesince 17 Feb 2003