Recital 63, Decision_act (EU) 2003/757

In forcesince 17 Feb 2003

Secondly, the Commission's abrupt withdrawal of its favourable decisions of 1984 and 1987 violates certain fundamental principles of Community law, in particular the principles of legal certainty and legitimate expectation. Thus Forum 187, citing European case law, stresses that there is a presumption of legality as regards the Commission decisions, and the Commission must state and explain its reasons for deciding that earlier decisions were unlawful (Papiers Peints(27)). It must do so within a reasonable time (Alpha Steel(28)). The addressee of a decision must be able to ascertain what obligations the decision imposes upon him (Gondrand(29) and Opel Austria(30)). The Commission was criticised for differences in interpretation between a decision of 1999 and five previous decisions concerning the same company (Kvaerner Warnow(31)). If the addressee of a decision fails to appeal within two months the decision can no longer be contested, and the same applies to the Commission because it declared that the scheme did not constitute State aid. Finally, the Commission, having approved a scheme, may not investigate each of the separate measures approved under this scheme (Italgrani(32)).