Recital 56, Decision_act (EU) 2003/757

In forcesince 17 Feb 2003

Firstly, it is inherent in the nature of a tax system to set limits on and conditions for the advantages and disadvantages it offers. Contrary to the Commission's claim, the Belgian system is based on the principle that companies, as "professional investors", are exempt, and not on the principle of systematic deduction of tax at source (see recital 38). Withholding tax is principally intended as a tax on natural and legal persons who are then released from an obligation: they are no longer required to declare the income from movable property that has been subject to withholding tax, because this constitutes the definitive tax on the income in question. The presentation of the regulations that apply here in the form of a principle followed by numerous exceptions reflects the desire of the legislator to include these regulations in a section of the 1992 Income Tax Code which is common to the four types of tax that are levied(23). According to Forum 187, it is inherent in the nature of a tax system to establish principles and to provide for exceptions to them. These exceptions will necessarily benefit some companies more than others. That does not mean that all of these exemptions have to be regarded as state aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty. It is therefore inappropriate to apply the provisions of that article to all of them.