By issuing the approval the tax administration assumed that the approved centre would comply with the conditions for benefiting from the exemption scheme of Royal Decree No 187 for 10 years, without having to prove every year that the conditions were being met. If the administration found that the conditions were no longer being met the centre would be excluded from the scheme in future. In accordance with the Belgian Constitution, these agreements related only to the facts and not to the scheme being implemented. They cannot, therefore, give any legal guarantee that the scheme, as it stood on the date approval was granted, would be maintained for the next 10 years. There is thus no contractual undertaking by the administration to the approved centre as regards the advantages conferred. This interpretation would seem to be supported by the reply from the Belgian State, which refers to its civil liability in connection with the losses a company might suffer, rather than its contractual liability to the company. The Belgian and European case law referred to by the Belgian State and the third parties regards respect for the principles of legal certainty and legitimate expectation in the same light. Careful reading of these judgments merely shows that the Commission may withdraw a decision with retroactive force only under very strict conditions, for example by allowing a reasonable time. However, if it applies the procedure for existing aid the Commission's action may not have retroactive force at all, given that it cannot recover aid. These judgments also state that the Commission may not, even in the future, withdraw its decision if this would cause unjustified hardship to the companies involved. Here, too, the procedure for existing aid guarantees the legal certainty of the companies by allowing the Commission the option, where necessary, of providing for a transitional period for phasing out the scheme.
Recital 118, Decision_act (EU) 2003/757
In forcesince 17 Feb 2003