Recital 161, Decision_act (EU) 2003/26

In forcesince 20 Dec 2001

In its Statement of Objections, the Commission reached the preliminary conclusion that TDI-grade toluene forms a distinct product market. The parties strongly dispute this finding on the basis of the following arguments: They submit that TDI-grade is not a fixed specification but several customers have their own differing specifications. Only a small proportion of TDI-grade toluene is sold to customers who need this high purity, whereas more than two thirds of the parties' production is sold to customers who could switch to lower qualities. According to the parties, there is also a high supply side substitutability as producers of lower grades could upgrade their equipment for the production of TDI-grade toluene with moderate investment. The fact that most producers replied to the Commission that this was not economically feasible results from the fact that only a small, or even non-existent premium is payable in respect of TDI-grade toluene compared to lower grades. The parties calculate that only a [small]* price premium would be required in order to allow the recovery of costs required to upgrade toluene production facilities to TDI-grade production. Only one of the several price quotation organisations publishes a spot price for TDI-grade toluene, but no contract prices are published. This is a further indication that no separate market exists for TDI-grade toluene. The parties further argue that there is an extremely high degree of correlation between the prices for the different grades (0,91 to 0,99). Although the published spot price shows periods of price premiums for TDI-grade, this does not reflect market realities. The spot market for TDI-grade is quite illiquid and only very small volumes are traded on this market. The parties' sales prices show that TDI-producers pay less than other customers of TDI-grade toluene, inter alia due to higher volume packages purchased.