The argument put forward by Hoffmann-La Roche, according to which it chaired the meetings because it was chairman of the ECAMA meetings, cannot exonerate it, since Hoffmann-La Roche was in no way coerced by the other participants and could have refused to assume chairmanship of the cartel and responsibility for collecting the sales data. That argument must therefore be dismissed. Similarly, the possibility that Hoffmann-La Roche adopted a "lower profile" in the cartel after chairmanship of the cartel meetings passed to Jungbunzlauer does not invalidate the Commission's finding that Hoffmann-La Roche played overall a leading role in the cartel.
Recital 272, Decision_act (EU) 2002/742
In forcesince 5 Dec 2001