Recital 263, Decision_act (EU) 2002/742

In forcesince 5 Dec 2001

Although successive meetings in January 1991 between ADM and, respectively, Haarmann & Reimer, Hoffmann-La Roche and Jungbunzlauer were characterised by ADM as being of an "introductory nature", the Commission is of the opinion that it is very likely that these meetings played a determining role in the establishment (or reestablishment) of the citric acid cartel in March 1991. In view of the very short lapse of time separating this series of meetings from the first multilateral cartel meeting of 6 March 1991, it is most likely that the possibility or intention of setting up a formalised cartel was discussed. This is supported in particular by the content of the discussions held, as reported by an employee of ADM: although the description of the discussions remains vague, the employee indicates that on two occasions at least, a competitor was "disparaged" for the manner in which it conducted its citric acid business. This expression of resentment against a competitor accused of not behaving properly in the market is clearly an indication of the anti-competitive purpose of introducing more discipline to the market.