Recital 227, Decision_act (EU) 2002/742

In forcesince 5 Dec 2001

Jungbunzlauer's argument based on the replies from various buyers of citric acid to the Commission's requests for information in January 1998 is not conclusive either. The question asked by the Commission concerning the intensity of competition in the market has to be seen in the context of a preliminary investigation into the main features of the citric acid market, and was therefore framed in general terms. Many replies merely point out that the citric acid market is worldwide, that several major players compete through quotations on the occasion of bids and that the price of the product has varied significantly over the years. The answers given to the Commission can in no way be construed as a demonstration of the inexistence of the effects of the cartel. In view of the high degree of sophistication characterising the illegal arrangements, one could certainly not expect the customers to be in a position to confirm the inexistence of competition in the market in question. It should also be noted that some replies drew attention to the broad similarity between the prices quoted by the main producers.