On the possible segmentation of markets according to specific applications, the notifying party submits that such segmentation would not be meaningful as pipe systems may be used in different applications and as pipe manufacturers can also produce pipe systems for different applications. Nevertheless, independent market studies and the market investigation carried out by the Commission indicate that the competitive conditions vary between different groups of applications. Utility companies and municipalities tend to buy pipes and fittings directly with the producers whereas products for domestic applications tend to be bought at DIY stores or with builders' merchants. Equally it seems to be uneconomical to substitute pipes and fittings meant for "non-pressure", or "gravity" applications (such as drainage pipes) with those fit for "pressure" applications, such as domestic hot and cold water pipes, water/gas utility pipes or pipes for industrial applications. Substitution in the other direction would be technically impossible. Also, the regulatory environment is different for many applications, as there exist, for instance, special norms for pipes carrying potable water or special plumbing codes. In a previous decision the Commission has considered it to be generally recognised that the relevant product markets for plastic pipes are constituted on the basis of each specific application, citing water pressure, gas pressure, sewage, drainage, electroprotection and irrigation. [4] In another decision concerning one specific application, the one for sewage pipes, the Commission has concluded that it constitutes a separate product market. [5]
[4] Case IV/M.565 - Solvay/Wienerberger, par.18.
[5] Case IV/M.1644- Wienerberger/DSCB/Steinzeug
The exact product market definition can, however, be left open in this case, because in all alternative market definitions considered, effective competition would not be significantly impeded in the EEA or any substantial part of it.
B. Relevant geographic markets
The parties submit that the relevant geographic market for pipe systems is the EEA because pipe systems produced in one Member State can be transported to and sold in another. Considerable competition would exist at both the international and European levels.