The economic sector concerned is the production and sale of pipe systems, comprising pipes and associated fittings, used to transmit fluids and gases. The notifying party submits that there is one single market for pipe systems. In a previous case [2], even though the precise market definition was left open, the Commission found that pipes and fittings would constitute separate product markets due to their different characteristics. The results of the market investigation carried out for the present case support this reasoning. Pipes and fittings are both sold and purchased separately and customers are able to combine products from different manufacturers. It seems therefore that pipes and fittings in general should be regarded as separate markets even though exceptions may exist, e.g. in highly specialised technical applications. In the present case it is, however, not necessary to decide on this question.
[2] Case IV/M.565 - Solvay/Wienerberger
The parties furthermore hold that pipes and fittings of plastic and of other materials belong to the same market. In a previous decision [3] concerning only one specific application (sewage pipes) the Commission has found that there is substitutability between pipes of clay, concrete, ductile iron, plastic and other materials. In the present case overlaps occur only in the sector of plastics as only one of the parties has a very limited presence in metal products. If the proposed operation does not create or strengthen a dominant position in the narrower market comprising only plastic products, it cannot create such a position in an alternative market comprising also non-plastic materials, because in the latter case the combined market shares would be lower. It is therefore not necessary to decide on this question either.
[3] Case IV/M.1644- Wienerberger/DSCB/Steinzeug