As to the specificity of the measure, it is worth noting that according to both the Commission's approach(13) and the case-law of the Court of Justice (see the judgments of 10 December 1969 in joined Cases 6 and 11/69 Commission v France(14) and 7 June 1988 in Case 57/86 Greece v Commission(15), a measure is specific and therefore must be regarded as State aid instead of a general measure where, although prima facie it might be seen as general in form, in practice it supports only a particular group of companies. In the present case, firstly, the tax measures under examination support those companies carrying out certain export activities and exclude companies that do not export as well as exporters that carry out export activities not covered by the provision and even exporters that carry out in Spain the type of investments covered by the provision. Secondly, apart from the fact that it has existed since 1978, neither the Spanish Government nor the interested parties which submitted comments have given any reasons why the tax measures in question are necessary to the functioning and effectiveness of the Spanish tax system(16). Thirdly, although it is true that the discretion of a public body in the application of a measure contributes to the classification of that measure as specific, the mere lack of discretion does not make the measure general.
Recital 20, Decision_act (EU) 2001/168
In forcesince 31 Oct 2000
Judgment of the Court of 10 December 1969. Commission of the European Communities v French Republic.Decision
10 Dec 1969 · 61969CJ0006
Judgment of the Court of 7 June 1988. Hellenic Republic v Commission of the European Communities.Decision
7 Jun 1988 · 61986CJ0057