Recital 29, Decision_act (EU) 2001/89

In forcesince 23 Jun 1999

The fact that an institution is under the dominant influence and protection of the government, as in the case of CFF, is reflected in the abnormal evolution of its rating. Although certain institutions may be in serious financial and economic difficulty, where the government retains some form of control over them the rating assigned to their borrowings does not deteriorate. To demonstrate this process, Moody's has developed a system of bank financial strength ratings which give an assessment of the stand-alone financial soundness of an institution, i.e. without any potential outside support(5). The evolution of CFF's ratings are highly indicative in this respect. Its bank financial strength was downgraded by Moody's between 30 August 1995 and 1 May 1996 from C + to E (the lowest possible rating) despite the French Government's intervention to support it between January and April 1996. By contrast, Moody's did not modify CFF's long-term debt rating, which it gave as Baa1 in early 1996, and confined itself to changing its forecast from negative to positive after the statements made by the Government at the end of April.