Recital 86, Decision_act (EU) 1999/395

In forcesince 28 Oct 1998

On the basis of the information provided by the Spanish Government, Torrelavega City Council appears to have acted in such a manner as to protect all those claims against SNIACE which it is legally able to enforce under Spanish law. The Commission has also examined whether the public creditor's behaviour in this case was determined by the intention to maximise the chances of recovery of the unpaid taxes and whether its actions were comparable to those of the private creditors. As the Commission acknowledged when opening the procedure, by not subscribing to the private creditors' agreement of October 1996 (which stipulated inter alia the conversion of 40 % of the debts into shares) within the framework of the suspension of payments procedure, the public authorities were able, in principle, to protect their entire claims. In addition, the Commission can accept that the separate agreement between Torrelavega City Council and SNIACE, which effectively went in parallel with the creditors' agreement, does not appear to have accorded SNIACE any more generous treatment than that reached in the private creditors' agreement. On the contrary, the "release" from debts was confined essentially to amounts which could not actually be recovered, notably since the company was not economically active for much of 1995 and 1996 and that the amounts due have consequently to be reassessed, though no details of the modified assessments have yet been provided to the Commission.