Recital 82, Decision_act (EU) 1999/395

In forcesince 28 Oct 1998

Notwithstanding the fact that the Social Security Treasury has acted in accordance with the applicable legislation, the treatment of SNIACE's debts, through various rescheduling agreements, does not seem to have been consistent with prevailing market conditions. The Commission's practice has been to make a comparison with the value at the relevant time of the reference rate fixed for the Member State concerned. However, no such rate was fixed for Spain until August 1996. Therefore, in determining whether or not such a rate is consistent with market conditions, in previous cases involving rescheduling of social security debts(4), the Commission has made a comparison with the prevailing average rate of interest charged by private banks in Spain on loans over more than three years. In this case, according to statistics published by the Spanish Central Bank, the average rate of interest charged by private banks on loans longer than three years during the period in question was as follows: 1991 18,24 %; 1992 17,28 %; 1993 16,19 %; 1994: 12,51 %; 1995: 13,09 %; 1996: 11,06 %(5). The other conditions of the rescheduling agreements, with the bulk of the repayments of principal and interest timed towards the end (apparently in order to facilitate the company's recovery) are also not in confomity with credits under normal market conditions.