Recital 5, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report for 1997

In forcesince 20 Apr 1998

in the case of complaints concerning work relationships between the institutions and bodies and their officials and servants, the possibilities for submission of internal administrative requests and complaints must have been exhausted before lodging the complaint (Article 2(8)).

Examples of inadmissible complaints

In October 1997, a Greek Ph.D. researcher in international and Community law complained to the Ombudsman against the European Commission.

The complaint was based on the following facts. In 1990 he had been excluded, on the basis of his nationality, from competitions organised for posts as a university researcher by the Law School of 'La Sapienza` University in Rome and the Instituto universitario di lingue moderne in Milan. He complained to the Commission by letters in March and June 1990 that his exclusion from the competitions infringed Article 48 of the EC Treaty. According to the complaint to the Ombudsman, although the Commission replied to his letters in May and July 1990 it had not taken satisfactory steps to deal with the discrimination.

The Ombudsman decided that the complaint was inadmissible because the complainant had not contacted the Commission since July 1990, that is for a period of seven years before complaining to the Ombudsman. The time limit of two years established by Article 2(4) had thus been considerably exceeded.

(Complaint 937/97/OV)

A company complained to the Ombudsman against the Commission in relation to a tender procedure in which it participated. The tender used the restricted procedure and was for provision of transport services for the diplomatic bag and other post.

According to the complaint, the facts were as follows. The Commission invited the company to submit a tender, with a deadline of 29 September 1997. On 10 September and 24 September the company requested further information and clarification about certain aspects of the tender documents. On 19 September and 25 September the Commission replied that it was unable to provide the information requested.

According to the complainant, whoever held the previous contract had the advantage of having more background information. The company therefore complained to the Ombudsman whom they asked to clarify the situation.

Although the complainant had been in contact with the Commission during the tender procedure, there was no indication that they had made the Commission aware of their dissatisfaction with the conduct or outcome of the tender procedure. The Ombudsman therefore decided that the complaint was inadmissible, since appropriate administrative approaches had not been made as required by Article 2(4) of the Statute.

The complainant company was advised to contact the Commission, setting out clearly its concerns about the tender process. If it was dissatisfied with the Commission's response, it could then address a complaint to the Ombudsman.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber, extended composition) of 19 October 1995. John Carvel and Guardian Newspapers Ltd vDecision

    19 Oct 1995 · 61994TJ0194

  • Treaty establishing the European Community48Law