, Special Report No 3/98 concerning the implementation by the Commission of EU policy and…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1998
139.

Further consideration needs to be given to the effective implementation of the polluter-pays principle in relation to water pollution. In principle charges and taxes need to be set in such a way that not only is sufficient revenue secured to meet both the capital and operational costs of the facilities concerned, but also more significant polluters have an incentive to improve their practices in order to reduce the impact of the taxes or charges they would otherwise have to pay. The Court is concerned that there might be a conflict between the normal requirement, whereby revenue generated by projects is taken into account in determining the amount of EU finance to be made available, and the polluter-pays principle: in order to qualify for maximum EU assistance, authorities in the Member States may be discouraged from ensuring that the principal polluters bear their proper share of the costs and face the correct financial incentives to reduce pollution at source and so reduce the burden on public infrastructure (see paragraphs 128-134).

140.

There is scope for improvement of coordination within the Commission. While DG XI has the primary responsibility for EU environmental policy, and for action to enforce the Directives, it needs to strengthen its links with other operational DGs in the Commission to ensure that the programmes and projects for whose execution they are responsible are fully consistent with the EU's environmental objectives (see paragraph 8).

141.

The fifth environmental action programme presented to the Council in February 1993 fixed the main lines of Community action for the medium and long term for the development of all sectors of economic activity associated with environmentally sustainable development. It also set a timetable for the attainment of the programme objectives. As regards sewage treatment, the difficulties highlighted by the Court in this report could make it difficult for the fifth programme objectives to be achieved by the year 2000. This uncertainty is shared by the Commission and Parliament which have also stated that there has been a lack of progress in combating water pollution. Positive action must be undertaken by the Commission and the Member States, well in advance of the deadlines for implementation that have been laid down in the directives, in order to redress the present situation (see paragraphs 3, 5, 24-28 and 51).