HB argues that, in the absence of its ability to enforce cabinet exclusivity, the competitive playing field would be tilted against it as a supplier which provides freezer cabinets in favour of those who do not. It says that other ice-cream suppliers would be able to offer preferential terms to retailers in that they would not be carrying the cost of freezer cabinet provision. HB has said that its natural reaction in such circumstances would be to discontinue making freezer cabinets available to retailers. In relation to this argument it should be remembered that there is no question of the application of Article 85(1) (where Article 85(3) is found to be inapplicable) to the exclusivity provision in HB's freezer-cabinet agreements not permitting HB to use whatever methods it chooses of recouping the investment it has made in freezer cabinets. Such methods need not have the consequence that other ice-cream suppliers benefit from HB's investment (paragraphs 218 and 219).
Recital 229, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531
In forcesince 11 Mar 1998