Recital 76, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531

In forcesince 11 Mar 1998

Until March 1995, HB supplied its ice-cream products and freezer cabinets at an 'inclusive` price. This price included the capital costs of the cabinet, its maintenance costs and the value of the ice-cream products. All retailers were charged the same price irrespective of the ownership of the cabinets in which the products are stocked. Thus, a retail outlet with its own freezer cabinet paid the same price for HB ice cream as a retailer accepting the offer of an HB freezer. In the 1993 Statement of Objections (see paragraph 5), the Commission reached the provisional conclusion that this pricing policy infringed Article 86 of the EC Treaty in that it discriminated against retailers who had not taken an HB freezer cabinet, but who none the less purchased HB ice cream. The Commission provisionally concluded that the inclusive pricing policy not only served as an inducement to grant exclusivity, to the detriment of competing suppliers of impulse ice cream, but that it also gave rise to discrimination between trading partners, by treating dissimilar situations in a similar fashion. Retailers with their own freezer cabinets effectively paid for a service which they did not receive and, in so doing, were forced to subsidise cabinet provision to those taking HB cabinets; the former retailers thereby placed themselves at a competitive disadvantage vis-à-vis the latter ones.