Recital 228, Decision_act (EU) 1998/531

In forcesince 11 Mar 1998

In relation to this contention, it must be pointed out that it is unlikely that retailers would cease altogether to be offered freezer cabinets, on whatever terms, by HB in any but a small number of instances, were it to be restricted in its ability to impose an exclusivity obligation in relation to those cabinets. The commercial reality for a company like HB, wishing to maintain its position of strength on the market, is that it will seek to be present in as many outlets as possible, even in those with lower levels of impulse ice cream sales. As described above, widespread visibility and availability are important for all impulse products. The need to ensure sales and thus profit levels provides sufficient incentive for an ice-cream supplier, particularly one with a range of products and a share of the market as important as HB's, to continue ensuring that retail outlets are able to stock its products for sale to consumers. Moreover, even where the freezer cabinet/s in an outlet would no longer be subject to exclusivity, it is likely that the products stocked in the cabinet/s would more or less reflect the different market shares of the various different manufacturers in the relevant market. HB could therefore expect, on the strength of its product offering alone, to continue to achieve a very substantial share of ice-cream sales in such outlets. HB is accordingly unlikely to run the risk of losing these sales altogether by ceasing to make freezer cabinets available to outlets which would otherwise not choose to continue stocking ice cream at all. HB has, in any event, a policy of only providing freezer cabinets to retailers on the basis of certain established financial and trading criteria which ensure a minimum return on HB's investment (see paragraph 62), with the consequence that the least important outlets in the relevant market are often not currently provided with HB freezers. It should also be pointed out, in this regard, that most of the recent cabinet disposals by HB took place in low-turnover outlets (see paragraph 73).